crimeUnder review

Samson’s Take on Adu-Boahene: GHS49.1m stolen, or a story the evidence cannot sustain

Samson’s Take on Adu-Boahene: GHS49.1m stolen, or a story the evidence cannot sustain

The High Court on Thursday dismissed an application by lawyers for former National Signals Bureau Director General Kwabena Adu Boahene and his co-accused to strike out portions of the Attorney General’s written submissions. Remember the famous ambulance trial involving Dr Cassel, Ato Forson and Richard Jakpa.

The High Court on Thursday dismissed an application by lawyers for former National Signals Bureau Director General Kwabena Adu Boahene and his co-accused to strike out portions of the Attorney General's written submissions.

Any suggestion that this signals the outcome is completely ignorant commentary on the law and procedure. Justice Achibonga's holding is essentially that a complaint about smuggling evidence or wrong attribution of testimony is immaterial because the court will only rely on the evidence on record and not merely what a lawyer says about it in his submissions.

If nonexistence evidence is found out, the court will expunge it. In fact, this early stage is only for prima facie determination and not pronouncement of guilt. Remember the famous ambulance trial involving Dr Cassel, Ato Forson and Richard Jakpa.

The High Court rejected their no-case submissions, but the Court of Appeal overturned that decision, acquitting and discharging them without requiring them to enter or, as we say, open their defence. That is precisely the kind of early termination the Adu Boahene defence now seeks.

If they are unsuccessful, they get to make their full case in a full trial. The question at this stage is whether the prosecution has presented enough evidence to require the accused persons to defend themselves at all. After calling four witnesses, the prosecution closed its case.

The defence has filed a 142-page submission of no case to answer. The Attorney General has responded in 25 pages, insisting there is a case to answer. When Attorney General Dr Dominic Ayine first announced this case, he alleged that 49.1 million Ghana cedis had been stolen through a fictitious US$7 million cybersecurity procurement.

He also spoke of luxury vehicles, expensive houses and properties abroad. NewsFile examined those allegations extensively. I took some flak for appearing to defend the Attorney General's decision to announce them publicly.

My position remains: the Attorney General has a right to inform the public, but the right to announce allegations is not a license to pronounce guilt. I'm a lawyer; I know that too well.

NewsFile has continued following the trial. We have even made a formal information request to ISE Holdings Limited, the Israeli company at the centre of the alleged procurement. But let's find out why the defence believes they have no case to answer. Here are five points from their 142-page submissions.

First, was the entire 49.1 million stolen? That's a question they ask. The defence acknowledges that three cheques were issued and the money moved. But they dispute the allegation that the entire amount was dishonestly appropriated. They point to banking records and transactions involving the National Security Coordinator as they seek to discount a total of 34 million Ghana cedis.

That's nearly 70% of the 49.1 million allegedly stolen. The prosecution has the burden to satisfactorily trace these funds and establish which transactions constituted dishonest appropriation. Money moving through an account is not by itself proof of theft.

The second argument important to the defence is that they ask the question: who authorised the transactions anyway, to be able to prove a crime? The defence argues that the source account was controlled by the National Security Coordinator for special security operations. They also rely on evidence that the coordinator signed or authorised the cheques. That's the difficulty they put the prosecution in.

The coordinator, at the material time, is deceased. But why were other appropriate national security officials not called to clarify the authorisation procedures and purpose of the payments? That's a question they ask. National security cannot excuse stealing, but neither can the institutional framework be ignored when determining whether stealing occurred.

Third, they ask, was the cybersecurity procurement fictitious? This was central to the Attorney General's original public pronouncement. The defence challenges the prosecution's account of the contracts, invoices, and alleged non-delivery. They point to documents concerning ISE Holdings Limited and argue that the prosecution has not established that the procurement was fictitious.

That is why Newsfile has sought information directly from ISE Holdings Limited. Was there a genuine contract? What was paid for? What was supplied? The allegation of fictitious procurement must equally rest on evidence.

Fourth, what became of the luxury properties so prominently announced? The Attorney General's initial disclosures painted a picture of substantial personal enrichment. The defence challenges whether the prosecution has established that the identified houses, vehicles, and other assets were acquired with the allegedly stolen funds.

Owning expensive property may attract the attention of law enforcement. They concede, but it does not, without more, prove that stolen money paid for those properties.

Fifth, and finally, what independently establishes the criminal involvement of Adu- Boahene's wife? The defence challenges whether the corporate relationship and financial transactions relied upon by the prosecution establish that Angela Adjei Boateng knowingly participated in the alleged crimes. Marriage is not conspiracy. Directorship is not proof of criminal intent.

Proof she did any wrong. The defence shouts the law loudly. I defended the Attorney General's right to inform the public when the case broke. I equally defend the accused person's right to challenge the allegations and insist that the state meet its burden. Accountability demands scrutiny of both those accused of stealing public money and those entrusted with prosecuting them.

So, after four witnesses, has the state established a case to answer on the alleged 49.1 million Ghana Cedi's theft? The supposedly fictitious procurement, the disputed assets, and the criminal responsibility of each accused? While the public commentary points to holes in the prosecution's case, the decision rests with the judge.

What matters is what the evidence actually establishes, not even the dramatic announcement and confident predictions at the start of the case or what you say. Let's never confuse the power to ….. with the proof required to convict. And that is my take.

  • evidence
  • case
  • defence
  • general
  • court
  • attorney
  • submission
  • security

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Koome reports 2.5pc drop in case backlog, says more cases cleared than filed
crime

Koome reports 2.5pc drop in case backlog, says more cases cleared than filed

NAIROBI, Kenya, Nov 20 — The Judiciary resolved more cases than were filed for the second consecutive financial year, reducing the overall pending caseload by 2.5 per cent, Chief Justice Martha Koome has announced. Expansion of court services The Judiciary expanded its geographical reach during the year, establishing two new Court of Appeal stations in Kakamega and Meru, operationalising the Eldoret Court of Appeal station and opening an Embu sub-registry.

Read →
Alternative Dispute Resolution reduces court backlog by over 41,000 cases
crime

Alternative Dispute Resolution reduces court backlog by over 41,000 cases

Justice Gabriel Pwamang, Acting Chief Justice, said the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Programme has reduced traditional courts’ caseload by 41,431 cases since its introduction in 2005. Justice Pwamang announced this when he launched the 2026/2027 Legal Year ADR Week at the High Court in Tamale on Monday, saying ADR has become a significant tool for improving access to justice and easing pressure on the judicial system.

Read →
I’m The Most Transparent, Vilified But I Shall Be Vindicated — Yahaya Bello
crime

I’m The Most Transparent, Vilified But I Shall Be Vindicated — Yahaya Bello

Former Kogi State Governor, Yahaya Bello, has expressed confidence that he will eventually be vindicated over the allegations of financial misconduct levelled against him by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC). In February 2026, an EFCC witness, Olomotane Egoro, told the Federal High Court that Bello’s name did not appear as a beneficiary, signatory, or party to transactions involving some companies allegedly awarded local government contracts in Kogi State.

Read →
Viral Video: Military uniforms found with bandits not from us – DHQ
crime

Viral Video: Military uniforms found with bandits not from us – DHQ

Reacting to the video, the Director of Defence Media Operations, Maj. Gen. Michael Onoja ruled out the possibility that the uniforms were supplied by the military. In February 2024, the Federal Government reiterated restrictions on the unauthorised use of military camouflage by civilians, warning against the misuse of security uniforms and equipment by criminal elements Minister of State for Defence, Bello Matawalle had stated that the restrictions were necessary to enable security agencies to distinguish legitimate personnel from impostors.

Read →