sports

Strategy, succession planning needed for Australia after Cape Town collapse

Strategy, succession planning needed for Australia after Cape Town collapse

After a disastrous series loss to South Africa, Australian cricket faces some tough decisions.

Fri, 11 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, IAW 117, AAW 4/121

Mon, 14 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, ZIM 235, AUS 8/294

Mon, 14 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, IAW 7/148, AAW 2/178

Wed, 16 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, IAW 161, AAW 5/168

Thu, 17 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, ZIM 272, AUS 6/356

Thu, 17 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, INU 6/182, AUU 7/175

Thu, 17 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, WAU 9/238, SAM 0/58

Fri, 18 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, QUE 7/335, VIC 7/339

Sat, 19 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, ZIM 8/271, AUS 9/272

Sat, 19 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, IAW 6/239, AAW 235

Sat, 19 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, WAU 115, TAS 1/117

Sun, 20 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, INU 7/341, AUU 239

Mon, 21 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, QUE 358, NSW 6/359

Tue, 22 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, IAW 6/338, AAW 8/341

Tue, 22 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, INU 4/255, AUU 254

Tue, 22 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, SAM 7/383, TAS 8/376

Wed, 23 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, SAF 8/297, AUS 230

Thu, 24 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, IAW 6/364, AAW 9/362

Thu, 24 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, INA 334 & 199, AUA 171 & 200

Thu, 24 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, VIC 212, NSW 257

Sat, 26 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, SAF 9/365, AUS 333

Mon, 28 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, INU 494, AUU 217 & 229

Mon, 28 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, SYW 4/168, QUW 167

Mon, 28 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, VIW 8/293, SAS 7/290

Mon, 28 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, WAW 6/236, TAW 232

Tue, 29 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, SAF 4/145, AUS 9/322

Wed, 30 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, IAW 364 & 257, AAW 176 & 164

Wed, 30 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, SYW 174, QUW 4/285

Wed, 30 Sept, 11:00 pm, Final score, WAW 7/273, TAW 7/299

Thu, 1 Oct, 2:00 pm, Final score, VIW -, SAS -

Thu, 1 Oct, 11:00 pm, Final score, INA 167 & 9/310, AUA 358 & 4/173d

Tue, 6 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, INA 149, AUA 274

Tue, 6 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, QUW 9/266, BAW 7/196

Wed, 7 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, INU 315 & 0/11, AUU 174 & 151

Fri, 9 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, AUW 3/168, BAW 166

Fri, 9 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, INA 206, AUA 275

Sat, 10 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, VIC 244 & 224, SAM 508

Sun, 11 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, AUW 1/222, BAW 6/220

Sun, 11 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, INA 275, AUA 226

Sun, 11 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, NSW 9/500d, TAS 245 & 5/402

Sun, 11 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, WAU 175 & 8/201, QUE 307 & 68

Mon, 12 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, VIC 241, SAM 311

Mon, 12 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, HHW 7/127, ACM 100

Mon, 12 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, SSW 3/136, BHW 90

Mon, 12 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, MRW 7/138, PSW 4/139

Mon, 12 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, STW 3/79, MSW 78

Tue, 13 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, SAF 284 & 206, AUS 390 & 6/314d

Tue, 13 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, NSW 158, TAS 203

Tue, 13 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, WAU 246, QUE 261

Tue, 13 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, SSW 3/78, ACM 7/77

Tue, 13 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, ASW 4/183, PSW 8/182

Tue, 13 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, STW -, BHW -

Wed, 14 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, AUW 2/175, BAW 172

Wed, 14 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, MRW 4/180, MSW 6/179

Wed, 14 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, ASW 5/165, HHW 8/136

Fri, 16 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, BHW 4/86, ACM 83

Sat, 17 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, SAM 7/397, QUE 271

Sat, 17 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, HHW 5/136, PSW 8/166

Sat, 17 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, STW 5/122, MRW 9/121

Sat, 17 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, ACM 4/129, MSW 6/132

Sat, 17 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, SSW 9/105, ASW 6/143

Sun, 18 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, AUW 8/165, NZW 2/162

Sun, 18 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, MRW 2/132, HHW 8/129

Sun, 18 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, BHW 129, ASW 6/139

Sun, 18 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, STW 2/93, PSW 92

Sun, 18 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, SSW 8/155, MSW 5/158

Sun, 18 Oct, 7:15 pm, Live score, AUW -, BAW -

Tue, 20 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, AUW 7/167, NZW 8/127

Tue, 20 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, ASW 6/116, PSW 5/118

Tue, 20 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, STW 9/152, SSW 6/153

Tue, 20 Oct, 7:15 pm, Live score, AUW -, BAW -

Wed, 21 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, SAM 203 & 145, QUE 238 & 4/114

Wed, 21 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, PSW 7/134, SSW 8/149

Thu, 22 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, SAF 9/425d, AUS 99 & 295 f/o

Thu, 22 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, AUW -, NZW 2/11

Thu, 22 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, TAS 241 & 236, VIC 207 & 266

Thu, 22 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, WAU 339 & 9/244, NSW 6/440d & 5/262d

Thu, 22 Oct, 7:15 pm, Live score, AUW -, BAW -

Sat, 24 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, TAS 137, VIC 7/304

Sat, 24 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, WAU 293, NSW 8/371

Thu, 29 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, MRW 9/138, STW 4/140

Thu, 29 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, MSW 4/192, HHW 8/174

Fri, 30 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, BHW 5/154, SSW 6/157

Fri, 30 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, AU6 3/135, ONG 4/107

Fri, 30 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, EN6 0/121, AU6 4/159

Sat, 31 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, SAF 329 & 387, AUS 429 & 111

Sat, 31 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, ASW 2/185, MSW 7/164

Sat, 31 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, PSW 1/138, MRW 6/136

Sat, 31 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, SAM 154 & 316, WAU 5/406d & 169

Sat, 31 Oct, 12:00 am, Live score, TAS 427, NSW 8/174

Sat, 31 Oct, 12:00 am, Live score, QUE -, VIC 9/282

Sat, 31 Oct, 12:00 am, Final score, AU6 3/141, UE6 6/88

Sun, 1 Nov, 3:40 pm, Game not started, STW versus BHW

Sun, 1 Nov, 6:10 pm, Game not started, AU6 versus AFG

Sun, 1 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, SSW versus HHW

Mon, 2 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, MSW versus PSW

Wed, 4 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, HHW versus MRW

Thu, 5 Nov, 3:40 pm, Game not started, ASW versus BHW

Thu, 5 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, STW versus PSW

Fri, 6 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, MSW versus SSW

Sat, 7 Nov, 2:30 pm, Game not started, WAU versus ENG

Sat, 7 Nov, 3:40 pm, Game not started, MRW versus ASW

Sat, 7 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, BHW versus HHW

Sun, 8 Nov, 1:40 pm, Game not started, SSW versus STW

Sun, 8 Nov, 5:10 pm, Game not started, PSW versus MSW

Tue, 10 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, HHW versus ASW

Wed, 11 Nov, 10:30 am, Game not started, NSW versus SAM

Wed, 11 Nov, 10:30 am, Game not started, VIC versus WAU

Wed, 11 Nov, 11:00 am, Game not started, QUE versus TAS

Wed, 11 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, PSW versus STW

Thu, 12 Nov, 3:40 pm, Game not started, MSW versus BHW

Thu, 12 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, MRW versus SSW

Fri, 13 Nov, 2:30 pm, Game not started, AUS versus ENG

Sat, 14 Nov, 3:40 pm, Game not started, HHW versus BHW

Sat, 14 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, PSW versus ASW

Sun, 15 Nov, 11:00 am, Game not started, SSW versus MRW

Sun, 15 Nov, 2:30 pm, Game not started, AUS versus ENG

Mon, 16 Nov, 10:00 am, Game not started, NSW versus SAM

Mon, 16 Nov, 11:00 am, Game not started, QUE versus TAS

Mon, 16 Nov, 2:00 pm, Game not started, VIC versus WAU

Mon, 16 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, STW versus MSW

Tue, 17 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, ASW versus SSW

Wed, 18 Nov, 2:30 pm, Game not started, AUS versus ENG

Thu, 19 Nov, 3:40 pm, Game not started, HHW versus PSW

Thu, 19 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, BHW versus STW

Fri, 20 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, ASW versus MRW

Sat, 21 Nov, 12:00 pm, Game not started, HHW versus STW

Sat, 21 Nov, 3:30 pm, Game not started, SSW versus PSW

Sat, 21 Nov, 7:15 pm, Game not started, AUS versus ENG

Sun, 22 Nov, 10:30 am, Game not started, NSW versus QUE

Sun, 22 Nov, 3:40 pm, Game not started, BHW versus ASW

Sun, 22 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, MSW versus MRW

Mon, 23 Nov, 1:30 pm, Game not started, WAU versus TAS

Tue, 24 Nov, 11:00 am, Game not started, SAM versus VIC

Tue, 24 Nov, 7:15 pm, Game not started, AUS versus ENG

Wed, 25 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, MRW versus BHW

Thu, 26 Nov, 3:40 pm, Game not started, STW versus ASW

Thu, 26 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, SSW versus MSW

Fri, 27 Nov, 7:15 pm, Game not started, AUS versus ENG

Fri, 27 Nov, 9:10 pm, Game not started, PSW versus HHW

Sat, 28 Nov, 3:40 pm, Game not started, MRW versus MSW

Sat, 28 Nov, 7:10 pm, Game not started, STW versus SSW

Sun, 29 Nov, 12:00 pm, Game not started, BHW versus PSW

Sun, 29 Nov, 3:30 pm, Game not started, ASW versus HHW

Sun, 29 Nov, 7:15 pm, Game not started, AUS versus ENG

Tue, 1 Dec, 7:10 pm, Game not started, versus

Wed, 2 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, AUS versus ENG

Thu, 3 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, NSW versus WAU

Thu, 3 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, VIC versus QUE

Thu, 3 Dec, 11:00 am, Game not started, SAM versus TAS

Thu, 3 Dec, 7:10 pm, Game not started, versus

Sat, 5 Dec, 7:10 pm, Game not started, versus

Wed, 9 Dec, 1:20 pm, Game not started, AUS versus NZL

Sat, 12 Dec, 8:10 pm, Game not started, MER versus PER

Mon, 14 Dec, 11:00 am, Game not started, SAS versus WAW

Tue, 15 Dec, 10:00 am, Game not started, ACM versus SYW

Tue, 15 Dec, 3:00 pm, Game not started, SLW versus AUW

Tue, 15 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, BRI versus SYS

Wed, 16 Dec, 11:00 am, Game not started, SAS versus WAW

Wed, 16 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYT versus ADE

Thu, 17 Dec, 10:00 am, Game not started, ACM versus SYW

Thu, 17 Dec, 11:30 am, Game not started, AUS versus NZL

Thu, 17 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, HOB versus BRI

Fri, 18 Dec, 3:00 pm, Game not started, SLW versus AUW

Fri, 18 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, MES versus ADE

Sat, 19 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, TAW versus VIW

Sat, 19 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYT versus SYS

Sun, 20 Dec, 3:00 pm, Game not started, SLW versus AUW

Sun, 20 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, PER versus HOB

Mon, 21 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, TAW versus VIW

Mon, 21 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, MES versus BRI

Tue, 22 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYS versus MER

Wed, 23 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, ADE versus SYT

Thu, 24 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, MER versus HOB

Sat, 26 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, AUS versus NZL

Sat, 26 Dec, 6:05 pm, Game not started, SYS versus BRI

Sat, 26 Dec, 9:15 pm, Game not started, PER versus MES

Sun, 27 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYT versus MER

Mon, 28 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, BRI versus ADE

Tue, 29 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, HOB versus MES

Wed, 30 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, PER versus SYT

Thu, 31 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, ADE versus MES

Fans of cricketing omens were treated to a masterful piece of psychological theatre before play on the final day of the Cape Town Test.

A week shy of 15 years since he rolled Australia for 47 at the same venue, former South African fast bowling genius Vernon Philander accompanied Proteas coach Shukri Conrad to the middle of Newlands and helped choose the ball to be used on the final day of this thrilling Test series.

Barely half an hour into play, Philander's most gifted successor, Kagiso Rabada, had used it to remove three of Australia's top order. With that, the game and Australia's fading hopes of winning the series were already dead and buried.

Chasing 288, which was always a huge ask, Australia buckled to be all out for 111, having earlier looked like securing its second sub-100 score in as many Tests.

The last Australian team to suffer that indignity at least had the good sense of doing it before the invention of television.

Whatever meagre sense of respectability Nathan Lyon and Pat Cummins restored with a 45-run partnership for the ninth wicket was cancelled out by the emphatic confirmation that Cummins had erred unaccountably by electing to bowl on day one and setting the stage for the impossible chase this one proved to be.

Proteas off-spinner Simon Harmer, who had quite boldly put Cummins on notice before this Test, spun his side to victory with 6-16 from 22 overs of wizardry.

Yet for all the bravado and posturing in this series, it was Harmer's lack of words, and his fighting back of tears when he picked up the man-of-the-match award, that best explained what this triumph means to South Africa.

There will be earnest post-mortems conducted to figure out where else Australia went wrong on this tour. The national selection panel should be interrogated first, and at length, yet so should several experienced batsmen who batted brainlessly at the critical moments that consigned Australia to a 2-1 series loss.

As most astute judges foretold, poor Marnus Labuschagne flubbed what will surely be his final chance at Test level. From the sixth delivery of a frantic day, the dejected Queenslander was trapped in front by Rabada and burned one final DRS review before trudging off with the weight of the world on his shoulders.

Still, we should not flatter Australia so much as to think of their miscalculations and mistakes as the most decisive factors in the resolution of this brilliant Test series.

Brimming with world-beating talent and self-belief, South Africa was simply better organised and better performed in almost every facet of the game.

So many of its players — Marco Jansen and Temba Bavuma in the second Test, Harmer, Ryan Rickelton and Wiaan Mulder in this one — can now say they produced career-defining performances when it mattered most. Would a single Australian?

Perhaps it was inevitable that Rabada would do something special after missing out in the first innings, when illness shrunk his powers.

But Harmer, whose performance was the most anticipated factor in the final day of the series, was the one who really played out of his skin.

His spell of 3-5 from eight spellbinding overs before lunch left Australia a Philander-esque 7-60, and the other wicket to have fallen at that point was also his in spirit: desperate to get off strike, Cameron Green called for a quick single that was not there and barbecued Josh Inglis.

Green hung around for 110 deliveries either side of lunch, but Harmer got him too with a raging turner that zipped through the gate.

Some tough and maybe unpopular decisions now await Australian cricket — not knee-jerk reactions to public outcry, and not wholesale personnel changes for now.

But there are matters of strategy and succession planning far more complicated than Marnus's sad slump into redundancy.

The world-class bowling attack which has papered over the cracks in Australia's batting line-up for several years will be, by the end of the coming Australian Test summer, aged 39, 37, 36, and 33, with a 37-year-old its best backup.

No matter how entitled each feels to his spot, and no matter how much career statistics and public sentiment justify that entitlement, some form of attrition is inevitable. Longer-term replacements urgently require game time in Tests, not cordial-mixing duties.

Cummins, who has the most left in the tank, and Lyon, perhaps the least, will be the unhappiest with their returns in this series — just six wickets each, at a cost of 54 apiece for Cummins and 43 for Lyon.

And it is hard to imagine South Africa picking someone to bowl a combined total of 25 overs in two Tests and bat at seven, as Australia did with Beau Webster.

It is not all doom and gloom, of course, and even in this game there were some positive glimpses into the post-Labuschagne, post-Smith era.

Matt Renshaw, streets ahead as the batsman of the series with 369 runs at 61.50, is a lock at the top of the order beside Travis Head. Proven performers now, Green and Inglis should be backed to succeed.

That leaves the number three and six slots to fill, with common sense suggesting Alex Carey needs to return to batting at seven.

That three has been made to appear such a fiendish problem is at odds with the solutions staring selectors in the face. Even in the era of "false threes", it is anathema to the history of the Australian Test team to pick anyone other than a top-order specialist in that crucial slot.

Steve Smith, if his appetite for a big finale remains, may need to be told it is his duty. If he or Australia decide it is time to move on, Kurtis Patterson is a mature and proven option who makes as much sense as Renshaw did for this tour.

As for six, it is a little early to tell exactly what, and how good, Cooper Connolly will be. But for generations it has been a spot that tends to be filled by a youthful player of promise and Connolly is both of those things.

Whichever way Australia goes with the above decisions, it is probably time that a coherent rationale for Test selection is more clearly communicated to contenders and even the public, because nobody who emotionally invests in Australian cricket is buying the strange stories George Bailey has been telling in recent times.

With all that, Australia now drops to third in the ICC Test rankings and New Zealand, who it faces in a Test series starting in 38 days, rises to the top.

If the Black Caps have prepared themselves for their challenge as diligently as South Africa did in this series, there will be plenty more difficult days ahead for Australia.

  • strategy
  • succession
  • planning
  • australia
  • cape
  • town
  • collapse
  • series

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Australia collapse on final day as Simon Harmer spins South Africa to series win
sports

Australia collapse on final day as Simon Harmer spins South Africa to series win

South Africa regain top spot in Test rankings Harmer takes career-best six for 16 at Newlands South Africa’s Simon ⁠Harmer took a career-best six for 16 as the hosts thumped Australia by 176 runs to clinch ⁠their three-test series 2-1 at ​Newlands on ‌Saturday. While Pat Cummins’s 90-ball vigil and Nathan Lyon’s unbeaten 33 in the hope of a draw delayed the inevitable, their fate was sealed Simon Harmer bowled Josh Hazlewood just before tea.

Read →
Australia set 288 to win on final day after South African centurions turn tide
sports

Australia set 288 to win on final day after South African centurions turn tide

Ryan Rickelton and Wiaan Mulder hit hundreds for hosts Australia face last-day chase to clinch Test and the series It would be unfair to say that Australia let a winning position slip on the fourth day of the third Test at Cape Town, only because that would undersell how Ryan Rickelton and Wiaan Mulder prised it away. In this series he was monstered in Durban by Josh Hazlewood, out for none and two while pinch-hitting as an opener, then made scant impression down the order with 31 in Gqeberha.

Read →