healthUnder review

The Guardian view on listening to people with learning disabilities: a matter of life and death

The Guardian view on listening to people with learning disabilities: a matter of life and death

The lessons have yet to be absorbed The fear that so many felt as the death toll rose during the Covid pandemic was magnified for Fiona Walker. Death rates in England were four to six times higher than average for people with learning disabilities.

The Covid pandemic shed an unforgiving light on health and social care inequalities. The lessons have yet to be absorbed

The fear that so many felt as the death toll rose during the Covid pandemic was magnified for Fiona Walker. “I know from experience they wouldn’t have valued my life,” she says, in a new report on the treatment of people with learning disabilities during the crisis.

The 1.5 million people in the UK with learning disabilities, and their families, had reason for concern. Death rates in England were four to six times higher than average for people with learning disabilities. As is now well established, the pandemic did not create inequalities; it exposed and intensified them. People with learning disabilities die on average 19.5 years earlier than people without, and deaths are almost twice as likely to be classed as avoidable.

Learning the lessons means listening to people with learning disabilities and their family carers. Ms Walker and others were commissioners for the new How We Survive and Thrive report led by Learning Disability England, working with researchers from the University of Birmingham and Manchester Metropolitan University. It describes how families were abandoned by planners in the pandemic, though carers and communities gave welcome support. While care homes were failed, the needs of those living in family homes or community settings were often simply overlooked.

Recommendations include prioritising patients with learning disabilities and finding ways to increase rather than decrease support in a future crisis. But other improvements would help now as well as in the next public health emergency: ensuring people are included on the GP learning disability register, and providing accessible information and reasonable adjustments. Reactions to treatment can be wrongly taken as a refusal of care, when they really point to the need for easier to understand information, or the presence of a carer who can explain to or advocate for the patient. As Mencap has pointed out, such adjustments can be the difference between life and death.

While many carers and health workers may provide remarkable support and treatment, professionals are not immune from society’s prejudices. The shocking imposition of “do not attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation” decisions on people with learning disabilities in the pandemic may have partially reflected initial advice from the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice). It said that patients should be assessed as scoring high for “frailty” – potentially affecting whether they received critical care – if they needed support with personal care, whatever the reason. Nice had to withdraw it. Testimony from patients with learning disabilities and their families suggests dangerous assumptions about patients’ quality of life also played a role. Those will be overcome only through sustained training and accountability.

Alarmingly, however, families and campaigners fear that progress made in recent decades is now being undone. Alongside cuts to social care packages and local support come profound challenges in healthcare. Important initiatives such as the Learning from Lives and Deaths scheme, examining the care received by people with learning disabilities and autism before their deaths, and mandatory training for healthcare staff on treating such patients, face growing funding pressures. The number of learning-disability nurses has fallen by a third since 2009 and student numbers are collapsing. That must be reversed. Learning disabilities should not mean a shorter life.

  • people
  • death
  • disability
  • life
  • pandemic
  • guardian
  • view
  • matter

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

‘You couldn’t become a doctor, but we’ll use you to heal the community’ – Al Sharpton to Javits
health

‘You couldn’t become a doctor, but we’ll use you to heal the community’ – Al Sharpton to Javits

American civil rights activist Rev. Al Sharpton has called on African American and immigrant communities to confront hatred and divisions among young people following the killing of 15-year-old Ghanaian Badu Nkansah Frimpong, popularly known as Javits. Delivering the eulogy at the teenager’s funeral in the Bronx, New York, on Friday, November 20, Rev. Sharpton said Javits’ death should serve as a wake-up call for communities to address hostility, particularly between people of African descent.

Read →
The best way to avoid winter illness
health

The best way to avoid winter illness

Responding to an article in the series The experts, Sally Billenness advocates wearing a mask and ensuring good ventilation. Sally Billenness Hounslow, London Continue reading...

Read →
The Guardian view on Jan van Eyck’s portraits: what it means to be human
lifestyle

The Guardian view on Jan van Eyck’s portraits: what it means to be human

Humanness is captured in every pore and wrinkle of all nine of Jan van Eyck’s portraits, united for the first time by the National Gallery. The paintings have been loaned from Berlin, Vienna, Dresden, Bruges and Sibiu in Romania, in a triumph of cultural exchange that proves the blockbuster show is still very much alive.

Read →
11 Dead, Over 180 Hospitalised After Drinking Illicit Alcohol In India
health

11 Dead, Over 180 Hospitalised After Drinking Illicit Alcohol In India

At least 11 people have died, and more than 180 have been hospitalised after drinking suspected tainted alcohol in India’s northeastern state of Manipur. In May, at least 15 people died after drinking methanol-laced illicit liquor in Pune and neighbouring Pimpri-Chinchwad in the western state of Maharashtra.

Read →