politics

Pay Attention by Laura Kuenssberg review – a BBC reporter’s howl of frustration

Pay Attention by Laura Kuenssberg review – a BBC reporter’s howl of frustration

After more than two decades of studied neutrality, the journalist delivers some home truths about modern politics Laura Kuenssberg always swore she would never write a book. She rarely complained even when she needed security to do her job unobstructed at Labour party conference under Jeremy Corbyn, or had to run the gauntlet of aggressive Brexit protesters outside parliament, or when a creepy unnamed minister tried to inveigle her into his hotel room for what an appalled Kuenssberg concluded was intended to be a threesome.

After more than two decades of studied neutrality, the journalist delivers some home truths about modern politics

Laura Kuenssberg always swore she would never write a book. Amid all the vitriol hurled her way, the BBC’s political editor turned presenter has largely kept her counsel. She rarely complained even when she needed security to do her job unobstructed at Labour party conference under Jeremy Corbyn, or had to run the gauntlet of aggressive Brexit protesters outside parliament, or when a creepy unnamed minister tried to inveigle her into his hotel room for what an appalled Kuenssberg concluded was intended to be a threesome. Knowing everything she does is minutely parsed for bias, she keeps her cards close to her chest. Until, apparently, something snapped.

Pay Attention is a muted but heartfelt howl of frustration with politicians “who have looked like an absolute shower for a long time” but also, sotto voce, with voters, who she evidently wishes would occasionally take things more seriously. Having covered Westminster since the late noughties, Kuenssberg brings all that weight of experience to bear in spelling out just how far the abnormal is now becoming normalised in British politics.

Once, she points out, there was a cross-party understanding not to inflame racial tensions at sensitive times; now masked men can roam Belfast seeking foreign-born people to burn from their homes, and still Nigel Farage says they shouldn’t be called far right. The Greens, Tories and Reform all selected candidates for this year’s council elections who had previously expressed startlingly flaky views. The rapid turnover of prime ministers over the last decade isn’t normal either, she argues, but nor was the behaviour causing it – from the boozy loucheness of Boris Johnson’s Downing Street to Keir Starmer securing a whopping great majority but no mandate, having never really made a case for what he actually wanted to do.

This is a serious and earnest book, not a gossipy insider’s tale, focused on the failures of governance that have radicalised what she argues isn’t naturally a radical country. Kuenssberg describes a politics paralysed by fear, with MPs afraid of telling an angry public the hard truths they’ll happily discuss with her once the camera stops running. (Nobody she talks to, apparently, thinks government operates effectively or spends money well.) But there are glimpses too of journalism struggling to hold politicians accountable, in an era of shrinking audience attention spans – Kuenssberg is notably sniffy about fluffy interviews that focus on a politician’s colourful backstory, not their policies – and Trumpian resistance to scrutiny.

She deconstructs the techniques Farage has developed to dodge questions he dislikes: expressing total conviction even when he doesn’t know the facts; turning questions back on his interviewer; and claiming to be persecuted by the media when cornered – an incendiary tactic Corbyn also adopted and which Zack Polanski is beginning to use, though Kuenssberg says at least Polanski has a “swagger and a bluntness” which means he’ll usually answer a straight question. When a politician lashes out at the mainstream media, she argues, pay extra attention to what they’re actually doing: often it’s a distraction tactic.

But she also identifies the weaknesses in mainstream politics that she believes gave Farage his opening. Ten years ago, she argues, it would have sounded “distressing and insane” to say there would soon be mass small boat crossings of the Channel: if that reality has changed, alongside the numbers of legal immigrants arriving and arrangements for housing them, perhaps it’s unsurprising that the public mood has changed, too. For Kuenssberg, it started with a wave of eastern European migration in the 2000s that some communities struggled to absorb, followed by the 2015 exodus of refugees from war-torn Syria and European leaders’ apparent impotence in the face of what she calls a “massive migration crisis”.

Politicians reacted first too slowly then too bombastically, promising to stop the boats and smash the gangs even when that wasn’t realistically possible, and fuelling the idea that immigration was beyond their control. What’s interesting about this argument – with which readers may agree or disagree – is that it is an argument, one of the few times she seemingly feels strongly enough to advance one.

There is a discernible tension here between Kuenssberg’s professional duty as a BBC journalist to remain politically neutral, and the need for a book to say something beyond the bleeding obvious. At times, I wondered if she wouldn’t have been better saving it all for a post-BBC memoir where she could let rip.

As it is, some readers will be outraged that she isn’t taking a stronger stand against extremism, while others will doubtless think she has outed herself as a moderate centrist merely by pointing out that ideas now advanced by both Reform and the Greens would once have been considered completely off the wall. As Kuenssberg knows better than most, you can’t win – though that doesn’t mean it isn’t worth trying. Sadly, I think she’s right that our politics is neither normal nor healthy, and that saying so in plain English is an important part of holding the line. But it will take more than paying attention, I suspect, to bring sanity back.

  • kuenssberg
  • attention
  • laura
  • bbc
  • howl
  • frustration
  • review
  • reporter

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Theresa May ‘aghast’ at Andy Burnham’s talk about rejoining EU
politics

Theresa May ‘aghast’ at Andy Burnham’s talk about rejoining EU

Former PM who opted for minimal ties with bloc says moves towards membership would dominate government’s time Theresa May has said she feels “aghast” at Andy Burnham’s plan for potentially rejoining the EU, arguing in a rare interview that the prime minister should “accept Brexit and move on”. Speaking to the BBC in the wake of Friday’s UK-EU summit, at which Burnham secured the biggest step towards renewed ties with Brussels since Brexit, May said that a further move towards membership again, as talked about by the PM, would dominate the government’s time.

Read →
A truism for our political leaders: until work again involves respect and decent levels of pay, this crisis will continue
politics

A truism for our political leaders: until work again involves respect and decent levels of pay, this crisis will continue

Last week’s Milburn review contained telling phrases, but the core problem is not Neets: it’s what capitalism as we know it has done to employment Everyday pride and contentment. But one of the tragedies of Labour’s 18 long years of exile from power and the climactic defeat of organised labour in the miners’ strike was the fact that they opened the way for the wholesale reinvention of work and watershed developments that we seem to be only just waking up to.

Read →
Pip review will call for overhaul rather than scrapping benefit for under-25s
politics

Pip review will call for overhaul rather than scrapping benefit for under-25s

Recommendations overseen by Stephen Timms would retain system for all ages, unlike last week’s Milburn review A long-awaited review into the personal independence payment (Pip) system will this week recommend that it is overhauled – a week after another report called for it to be partly scrapped. The final report into Pip by a committee co-led by Stephen Timms, the social security minister, is expected to be published as soon as Tuesday, presenting Andy Burnham with one of his most politically sensitive decisions yet as prime minister.

Read →
Peter Fluck obituary
politics

Peter Fluck obituary

Artist and caricaturist who co-created the hugely popular ITV satire Sptting Image with Roger Law Peter Fluck, who has died aged 85, was, with his fellow artist Roger Law, half of the Fluck & Law partnership that revived satire on TV with Spitting Image, the ITV puppet sketch show lampooning celebrities, politicians and the royal family. Two decades after the BBC’s That Was the Week That Was spoofed the British establishment and, in particular, the last days of Harold Macmillan’s Conservative government at the time of the John Profumo affair, Spitting Image, from 1984 to 1996, mined another pe

Read →