health

IVF patient fears Catholic takeover will affect quest to become a mum

IVF patient fears Catholic takeover will affect quest to become a mum

Moments before going into surgery, Hayley Deniss was told about a potential disruption to her IVF care.

Women going through IVF are worried about what Calvary Health Care's takeover of two private hospitals in Newcastle means for their care.

The Catholic provider has confirmed it will not allow IVF, elective abortions, voluntary assisted dying or gender reassignment surgeries for religious reasons if its takeover bid is successful.

The sale is still subject to a NSW government-issued hospital licence and a ruling by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission.

Hayley Denniss always wanted to start a family, but being single and living with three chronic health conditions has not made the process easy.

On October 29, about four years after she began her "gruelling" IVF journey, Ms Denniss went through her third egg collection at Newcastle Private Hospital.

Moments before she was due to be anaesthetised for the procedure, she was told the future of IVF services at the hospital was in doubt.

"The nurse said to me, 'I'm not sure what you're going to do after this, because Calvary don't believe in IVF,'" Ms Denniss said.

Catholic provider Calvary Health Care is hoping to take over 14 hospitals across the country by the end of the month, after embattled provider Healthscope went into receivership last year.

Six of those are in NSW, including the Newcastle and Hunter Valley private hospitals.

Calvary follows a Catholic code of ethics and has confirmed it will not allow IVF collections, elective abortions, voluntary assisted dying or gender reassignment procedures at any hospital it acquires.

Ms Denniss said her latest retrieval was one of the most successful yet, but the uncertainty about future collections and continuity of care has left her feeling uneasy.

"It's kind of hit me for six," she said.

"I'm having this elevated happiness … but then I'm like, 'Do I get to finish off that success?'

Hunter IVF operates adjacent to Newcastle Private and uses the hospital's operating theatres to complete egg collections and carry out surgical sperm procedures.

The service, which has been in operation for more than 20 years, has told its clients the business is here to stay.

"We're working really hard with alternate providers at the moment to ensure that there's no interruption to care," Hunter IVF doctor and fertility specialist Veronica Knight said.

Calvary has no ownership over Hunter IVF's embryo lab or clinic, but questions remain about where surgical procedures would take place.

"Egg collection procedures and embryo transfers are all very time-sensitive," Dr Knight said.

"Ideally those all need to happen on one site so the clinicians can move between those activities quickly."

Hunter IVF said it had its first one-on-one consultation with Calvary Health Care about the changes on October 30, a little more than a month out from the proposed sale date.

"These discussions were held very late, with not a great deal of notice for us to reallocate a lot of the logistics of our care," Dr Knight said.

The sale of the two hospitals is still subject to the transfer of a licence, granted by the NSW government, as well as a determination from the Australian competition watchdog.

The pending sale has sparked concerns about access to women's and community healthcare in regional NSW, where some patients travel for hours to receive specialised care in Newcastle.

On Sunday, hundreds of people rallied against the sale in Newcastle.

Ms Denniss said the decision not to offer IVF services for religious reasons was unfair to women who faced barriers to natural conception.

"We are not trying to play God," she said.

NSW Health Minister Ryan Park has vowed to work with other providers to ensure access to services continues across the region.

"We'll have a look at the volume of people utilising those services, then we will work out what capacity we have as a system and then work out what others may do," he said.

The minister said the intervention of the state in private hospital sales could put more community health services at risk.

"That includes cardiac services, anaesthesia, general surgery … a range of different services that we certainly don't want to see taken out of the community," he said.

Calvary Health Care declined multiple requests for an interview, but said in a statement that the acquisitions would provide greater stability for the hospitals, their employees and the community.

It said discussions with local clinicians were ongoing.

  • patient
  • takeover
  • quest
  • mum
  • ivf
  • moment
  • surgery
  • hayley

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Every cedi invested in Ghana’s healthcare must deliver measurable patient outcomes – CHAG Executive Director.
health

Every cedi invested in Ghana’s healthcare must deliver measurable patient outcomes – CHAG Executive Director.

The Executive Director of the Christian Health Association of Ghana (CHAG), Dr Peter Yeboah, is demanding greater accountability for healthcare spending, insisting that every cedi invested in the sector must translate into improved patient outcomes and protection against the financial burden of illness. Speaking to JoyNews on the sidelines of Queen Máxima of the Netherlands’ visit to Manna Mission Hospital in Accra, Dr Yeboah said the country must prioritise value for money in healthcare delivery to ensure that limited resources produce measurable benefits for patients.

Read →
How fragmented health data systems take time away from patient care
health

How fragmented health data systems take time away from patient care

The World Health Organisation (WHO) says this fragmentation is adding to the administrative workload of health workers in African countries, with implications for the time they can devote to caring for patients. Team Lead for Health Information, Knowledge Management, Digital Health and Artificial Intelligence at the WHO Regional Office for Africa, Dr Benson Droti, said some countries had allowed individual health programmes to develop their own information systems, resulting in duplicated reporting.

Read →
GMA proposes dedicated fund to finance emergency healthcare
health

GMA proposes dedicated fund to finance emergency healthcare

The Ghana Medical Association (GMA) is urging the government to establish a dedicated emergency healthcare fund to ease the financial burden on patients who require urgent medical attention but cannot afford treatment. Speaking to JoyNews after the Association’s 68th Annual General Conference, the GMA’s General Secretary, Dr Richard Salomey, said the government should consider creating a sustainable funding arrangement to support emergency care.

Read →
GPs to offer 300,000 patients extra support to ease winter strain on NHS
health

GPs to offer 300,000 patients extra support to ease winter strain on NHS

£40m scheme in England aims to keep most vulnerable people well at home and avoid unnecessary hospital stays Hundreds of thousands of vulnerable patients in England are to receive extra support from their GP as part of a £40m drive aimed at keeping them out of hospital this winter. As the NHS gears up for the pressures of the coming months, family doctors will offer 300,000 people with frailty and long-term conditions health checks, medication reviews and respiratory tests designed to prevent avoidable hospital admissions.

Read →