business

Is Nigeria, first, a cultural problem before it is a political or an economic one?, By Uddin Ifeanyi

Is Nigeria, first, a cultural problem before it is a political or an economic one?, By Uddin Ifeanyi

Nigeria’s biggest problem, today, is that inflation continues to outstrip wage growth. Fiscal indiscipline and a captive monetary policy establishment mean that our version of the “affordability crisis” will be the dominant narrative around the economy’s performance for a long while yet.

Nigeria’s biggest problem, today, is that inflation continues to outstrip wage growth. Fiscal indiscipline and a captive monetary policy establishment mean that our version of the “affordability crisis” will be the dominant narrative around the economy’s performance for a long while yet. As it should be. For these are but symptoms of a deeper malaise. Since 1960, our governments have struggled to properly optimise the constraints that they have been faced with. Put differently, few of them, and even among this contingent only infrequently, have been able to agree on what their priorities should be. When they do agree on goals, they cannot seem to sequence the implementation of the components of the many projects that these goals are made up of in a way that ensures that the goals are met within budget and on schedule. And then budgets across the different tiers of government leak through every crack in the system.

Why is this so? A ready scapegoat is a lack of voice. When, especially in the democracies that we have assayed now and again, votes do not count and or are not counted, it is difficult for the electorate to hold public officers to account. And as a result, it is easier for society to be saddled with governments that do not seem to know what they are doing. Add a criminal justice system that is almost broken beyond repair to the mix, and this cocktail of misfortunes mean that we have, as a people, consistently punched below our weight in the comity of nations. An arguably more consequential outcome is the damage that the resulting poor governance arrangement wrecks on our people — from elevated poverty levels, through poor health and education outcomes, to dreadful levels of economic inefficiency.

Understandably, the search for solutions to the country’s many problems has become an artisanal hobby. From bukkas to Point-and-kill joints, our federal constitution is reputed to be the main let to our efficient organisation. According to this reading of the problem, by returning to parliamentary democracy and regional governments, we not only solve the burden of an expensive presidential system. We cure the rest of the country’s ills to boot.

If this comes across as a case of running in the face of Occam’s Razor (“the principle that, among competing explanations, the one requiring the fewest assumptions should be preferred”), then it probably is. As with conspiracy theorising generally, the more elaborate the plot the more enticing it is as explanation. Stripped of their intellectual finery, however, these aspiring cures simply beg the question.

In our conversations, the main argument in favour of decentralisation is not the Roman Catholic Church-inspired notion of “subsidiarity” (the idea that requires that political decisions should be made at the most local level capable of addressing an issue, with higher authorities acting only when objectives cannot be effectively achieved locally). Rather, the conceit here is that with government closer to the people, popular oversight of government business will be improved. Would that this were so. The difficulty in all of this is that there are readily available counterfactuals across the land. Ordinarily, on this reckoning, we should have a clutch of sub-national and municipal governments where the performance bar is higher than the national average. But we do not.

Might the absence of such examples show that a simpler reason lies at the bottom of our national problems?

Whether in the private or public sector, the Nigerian big man’s preference is for loyalty over competence. The familiar, “our son”, over the other (“their son”). Attitude (deference to authority) over aptitude (education in the field in question and proven nous). And so, a president from the North (Muhammad Buhari) surrounds himself with northerners. A president from the South-West (Bola Ahmed Tinubu) with South westerners. And when in doubt over a subordinate’s fealty? March them all up to the top of the hill, where, at a shrine located there, they will be required to plight their troth to the “Leader” in blood oaths. Invariably, on the back of all this, from the police, through the judiciary, to the central bank, institutions’ ability to function as checks on themselves, and on executive power is eroded.

Is the Nigerian problem, then, a cultural one? Two things suggest that it might be. First, is our seeming inability to escape ways of thinking that have over the years delivered consistently suboptimal outcomes. If “Loyalty is the engine that drives a patronage economy; and those at the soft end of our version of this type of economy are not complaining about its contraindications, while the rest (otherwise victims of our apparently poor choices) are hoping, someday soon, to benefit from it”, as my friend insists is the case here, then (and this is the second argument in favour of a cultural provenance for our problems), it makes sense that we will continue to seek easy (nonviable) fixes.

Uddin Ifeanyi, a journalist manqué and retired civil servant, can be reached @IfeanyiUddin.

Mr. Udin is Business Intelligence expert. He is a Member of Premium Times Editorial Board and a Columnist par excellence.

  • nigeria
  • problem
  • uddin
  • ifeanyi
  • inflation
  • wage
  • growth
  • indiscipline

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

40m MSMEs hold key to Nigeria’s economic future, Uzodimma, business leaders say
business

40m MSMEs hold key to Nigeria’s economic future, Uzodimma, business leaders say

…Imo gov unveils blueprint for grassroots economic growth By Nnamdi Ojiego Nigeria’s nearly 40 million micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs), which account for close to half of the country’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and nearly nine out of every 10 jobs, hold the key to its economic future, Governor Hope Uzodimma of Imo State and business leaders have said. Delivering the keynote lecture entitled, “The Future Is Local: Stimulating Grassroots Economies for Inclusive Growth”, Uzodimma argued that Nigeria’s next phase of economic growth must come from its communities, particularly the…

Read →
Without manufacturing $1tr economy is an illusion
business

Without manufacturing $1tr economy is an illusion

By Dele Sobowale Japan in fact offers a relevant historical example of what can happen to an economy which falls behind in the global manufacturing race. The Gowon administration sent delegations to the United States in 1974 to appeal to young and well-educated Nigerians to return home and fill vacant positions opening up in manufacturing in several industrial layouts in Lagos, Ibadan, Kaduna, Kano, Portharcourt and Aba.

Read →
Without manufacturing $1trn economy is an illusion
business

Without manufacturing $1trn economy is an illusion

By Dele Sobowale Japan in fact offers a relevant historical example of what can happen to an economy which falls behind in the global manufacturing race. The Gowon administration sent delegations to the United States in 1974 to appeal to young and well-educated Nigerians to return home and fill vacant positions opening up in manufacturing in several industrial layouts in Lagos, Ibadan, Kaduna, Kano, Portharcourt and Aba.

Read →