Lawyer led out after making derogatory remarks in court against CJI
Of late, the court has expressed growing apprehensions about petitioners-in-person deliberately trying to ambush judges in open court rooms in full view of the cameras
This cautious stance may have been a result of past instances of chaotic disruptions during oral mentionings. File
A lawyer was led out of the Chief Justice of India’s courtroom after making disparaging remarks directed at Chief Justice Surya Kant on Monday (November 16, 2026).
The incident happened soon after the Bench, also comprising Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana, assembled at 2 p.m.
Chief Justice Kant had not presided over his Bench in the morning, and had joined only post-lunch. He had been on an official tour in Brazil during the latter part of the Deepavali holidays. November 16 was the first working day for the court after the festival vacation. The court circular had informed that the Bench would begin by hearing oral mentionings for early listings of cases, followed by any matters requiring a three-judge Bench combination.
The lawyer in question began by apologising to Justices Bagchi and Mohana, and said he had put a petition for the “favourable consideration of Justice Surya Kant”.
“This item was given to Justice Surya Kant 15 days back in his office on November 2, so I am forced to come before this court…” he said.
Justice Mohana interjected to caution the lawyer that he could not mention issues like this before the Bench. But the lawyer insisted. “I can. It is an emergency. I had submitted my apology first,” he said.
The Chief Justice said the court would look into the case. “Please wait,” the CJI addressed him.
At this, the lawyer replied that he would not wait. He made a derogatory comment about the “integrity” of the top judge. The audio-video feed was paused immediately after these remarks.
Subsequently, lawyers present in the courtroom said the lawyer in question was involved in a contempt case. Other lawyers in the court room, including Bar office-bearers intervened against such unsavoury remarks being made against the CJI in open court. The man was finally led out.
Recent past have seen oral mentionings being blanked out in the CJI court.
Oral mentionings is a routine usually witnessed as soon as the court assembles for the day. The lawyers are heard seeking urgent hearings, at times for safeguarding life, liberty and other fundamental rights. It is a unique window for lawyers and litigants to directly get the attention of the Chief Justice of India.
Of late, the court had expressed growing apprehensions about petitioners-in-person deliberately trying to ambush judges in open court rooms in full view of the cameras, and later using the unauthorised recorded visuals online to embarrass the judiciary and the institution.
What began with the CJI court blanking out oral mentionings by petitioners-in-person, gradually became a complete muting of the oral mentionings, regardless of whether they were made by a petitioner or a counsel. The feed would only resume once formal hearing began on the listed cases for the day.
This cautious stance may have been a result of past instances of chaotic disruptions during oral mentionings.
Chief Justice Kant’s immediate predecessor, Justice B.R. Gavai, had to face an abusive and unrepentant lawyer who hurled an object at his Bench, while a Vacation Bench headed by Justice K.V. Viswanathan suffered a few tense moments when sheaves of paper were thrown up into the air by another lawyer.
- court
- lawyer
- cji
- remark
- apprehension
- petitioner
- person
- judge

