Simply telling the AA about my minor no-fault, no-claim prang doubled my insurance quote

A recent £364 renewal quote suddenly increased to an extortionate £796 It had recently sent a renewal quote for £364, but after reporting the accident I was sent a revised figure of £796.86.
A recent £364 renewal quote suddenly increased to an extortionate £796
My car was involved in a minor no-fault accident. The other driver admitted responsibility and said they would pay for repairs without involving insurers. I informed my insurer, the AA, without making a claim. It had recently sent a renewal quote for £364, but after reporting the accident I was sent a revised figure of £796.86.
I was told by a call handler that any insurance company would do the same. However, they eventually lowered the quote to £452.31. This seems extortionate for a no-fault, no-claim prang.
You’re damned if you do and damned if you don’t. Failure to report an accident, even if it’s minor, not your fault and you don’t plan to claim, could invalidate your policy.
The algorithms that insurers use to assess risk tend to assume that one prang makes you statistically more likely to have another, regardless of blame. Plus, you, or the at-fault driver, might later decide to claim for said incident.
However, when I asked the AA how it justified doubling your premium, it discovered that its system and the call handler had boobed. It didn’t say what you should have been quoted, but has decided to honour the original £364 to make up for its failings.
We welcome letters but cannot answer individually. Email us at consumer.champions@theguardian.com or write to Consumer Champions, Money, the Guardian, 90 York Way, London N1 9GU. Please include a daytime phone number. Submission and publication of all letters is subject to our terms and conditions.
- quote
- prang
- insurance
- fault
- claim
- renewal
- accident
- insurer



