politicsUnder review

The UN Succession: Why Grynspan’s growing momentum matters to Africa

The UN Succession: Why Grynspan’s growing momentum matters to Africa

More significantly, 29 former foreign ministers from Latin America and the Caribbean signed an open letter on 10 November explicitly endorsing Grynspan and urging governments in the region to consolidate their support behind her. In its communication to the African Union, Abuja argued that it was the turn of Latin America and the Caribbean to produce the next Secretary-General, warning that disregarding the established understanding of regional rotation could jeopardise Africa’s interests in future selections.

The contest to choose the next Secretary-General of the United Nations is beginning to reveal something more consequential than the electoral fortunes of individual candidates. It is becoming a test of the international community's commitment to multilateralism, the credibility of its calls for institutional reform and the unwritten understandings that help preserve geographical balance in global leadership.

Costa Rica's Rebeca Grynspan is increasingly at the centre of that conversation.

In the eighth informal Security Council straw poll on 5 November, she secured 12 encouraging votes out of 15, improving on her previous showing of 11. Argentina's Rafael Mariano Grossi followed with nine, while Guyana's Carolyn Rodrigues-Birkett received eight. It was Grynspan's strongest performance yet, although three discouraging votes indicate that important reservations remain. The confidential, non-colour-coded ballot did not identify whether those objections came from permanent or elected members.

Her growing momentum has also been accompanied by more visible political support from Latin America and the Caribbean. At the Ibero-American Summit in Madrid, Costa Rican President Laura Fernández openly rallied support for Grynspan, arguing that the region had an opportunity to contribute to global leadership. Other regional leaders also made the case for Latin American representation and the election of a woman to the office.

More significantly, 29 former foreign ministers from Latin America and the Caribbean signed an open letter on 10 November explicitly endorsing Grynspan and urging governments in the region to consolidate their support behind her. The signatories argued that fragmented regional backing could weaken an important opportunity for Latin America and the Caribbean to lead the United Nations.

These developments matter because the Secretary-General selection process is not simply about which candidate collects the most favourable informal votes. It is about who can build the political consensus required to lead an organisation whose credibility is under considerable strain.

For Africa, however, the unfolding contest presents a particularly interesting dilemma.

The continent has had its own candidates in the race, most notably Senegal's former President Macky Sall and Uganda's Olara Otunnu. Sall's nomination was eventually withdrawn by Burundi on 20 October, while Otunnu remains in contention. Their candidacies deserve consideration on their respective merits, but the broader African debate has increasingly centred on the principle of regional rotation.

Nigeria was particularly emphatic on this question. In its communication to the African Union, Abuja argued that it was the turn of Latin America and the Caribbean to produce the next Secretary-General, warning that disregarding the established understanding of regional rotation could jeopardise Africa's interests in future selections.

South Africa has expressed a similar position. Foreign Minister Ronald Lamola publicly acknowledged that the unwritten convention pointed to Latin America and the Caribbean for this cycle, alongside his country's aspiration to see the first woman appointed to the position.

These positions are significant. Regional rotation is not a binding provision of the UN Charter, nor is there an automatic entitlement for any geographical bloc to produce the Secretary-General. The appointment is made by the General Assembly upon the recommendation of the Security Council. Nevertheless, geographical balance has become an important diplomatic understanding in the organisation's history.

For Africa, the principle has implications beyond the current contest.

If regional understandings can be disregarded whenever political circumstances become inconvenient, what assurance does the continent have that its own turn will receive similar consideration in the future? The question is not whether Africa should insist on an appointment regardless of merit. It is whether the conventions that help protect the interests of regions with less power should remain meaningful when the competition becomes difficult.

This is why the African position on the current succession should be understood as a question of institutional principle, not simply support for one candidate over another.

There is another dimension that deserves attention: the kind of leadership the United Nations needs.

The organisation is facing a crisis that cannot be resolved through better public relations or another round of administrative restructuring. Geopolitical divisions are constraining the Security Council, financial pressures are affecting operations and the international rules-based system is increasingly being tested by unilateral action and competing national interests.

The next Secretary-General must therefore be more than a diplomatic figurehead. The office requires someone with political judgement, institutional knowledge and the ability to translate negotiations into practical outcomes.

This is where Grynspan's professional record becomes relevant to the debate.

Her experience as Vice President of Costa Rica, Secretary-General of the Ibero-American Conference, UN Under-Secretary-General and Associate Administrator of UNDP, and subsequently Secretary-General of UN Trade and Development gives her an unusually broad perspective on government, multilateral diplomacy and institutional management.

At UN Trade and Development, she has consistently drawn attention to the structural inequalities in international trade and finance, including the debt pressures and high borrowing costs that constrain developing economies. Her engagement with Africa's industrialisation ambitions, regional integration and the need for greater local value addition in critical minerals speaks to challenges that are central to the continent's development agenda.

Her involvement in the Black Sea Grain Initiative also demonstrated the value of practical diplomacy in circumstances where geopolitical disagreements might otherwise have prevented progress.

None of this means that the Secretary-General can independently resolve the structural problems of the international system. The office is constrained by the political will of Member States, particularly the five permanent members of the Security Council. But the ability to understand these challenges, build coalitions and pursue institutional change is precisely what the next leader will require.

The question, then, is what it would mean for the credibility of UN reform if a candidate demonstrating considerable support across the Security Council, and bringing a substantial record of institutional and diplomatic experience, were ultimately prevented from advancing because of opposition from one or a small number of powerful members.

The permanent members have legitimate responsibilities under the Charter, including their veto powers. But the exercise of those powers also carries a responsibility to consider the wider interests of the organisation and its membership.

For Ghana, the debate inevitably brings Kofi Annan's legacy into focus.

Annan was the second African to serve as Secretary-General, following Egypt's Boutros Boutros-Ghali. His tenure demonstrated that the office could be used not merely to administer the international system but to challenge it, encourage institutional change and give greater visibility to issues that might otherwise struggle to command international attention.

There is no need to search for another Kofi Annan. The international environment has changed, and the next Secretary-General will face challenges of a different scale and character.

But the lesson of Annan's leadership remains relevant: defending multilateralism does not mean defending the status quo. Sometimes, preserving the credibility of an institution requires the courage to change it.

The succession should therefore be judged against more than regional arithmetic or the political preferences of individual powers. It should be about the kind of United Nations the world wants and whether its members are prepared to give that institution the leadership and political space required to become more effective.

For Africa, the stakes are twofold. It must protect the principles of geographical balance that help give smaller and developing regions a meaningful place in global leadership, while insisting that the next Secretary-General has the capacity to make the United Nations relevant to the challenges of the present.

The final decision will belong to the Security Council and the General Assembly. But the implications will extend far beyond New York.

They will speak to the future of multilateral leadership, the credibility of institutional reform and the place Africa can expect to occupy in shaping the international order.

That, ultimately, is why this succession matters.

The Author: Francis Doku is a Ghanaian media executive, journalist and strategic communications consultant with more than 25 years of experience across media, marketing communications, tourism and destination development. He is Founder and CEO of Maestro Africa Group, Publisher and Managing Editor of Africa Meets Magazine, and Executive Producer and Host of the Africa Rising Podcast. He also serves as West Africa Regional Director of Africa Tourism Partners and is a Consulting Editor and contributor to VoyagesAfriq. Doku writes on tourism, culture, international relations and Africa’s evolving engagement with the world.

  • africa
  • grynspan
  • general
  • latin
  • america
  • caribbean
  • momentum
  • secretary

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

COP31: Advocates urge funders to double clean air money for Africa, Asia and Latin America by COP32
politics

COP31: Advocates urge funders to double clean air money for Africa, Asia and Latin America by COP32

Clean air advocates at COP31 have urged philanthropic funders to double their annual support for air quality initiatives in Africa, Latin America and parts of Asia, warning that inadequate financing is undermining efforts to tackle pollution in some of the world’s most affected regions. “If you look at philanthropic funding for clean air in Asia excluding China and India, Africa and Latin America combined, it’s US$8.3 million a year.

Read →
₦70,000 Transport Controversy: FG Constitutes Committee To Review New Minimum Wages For Workers
politics

₦70,000 Transport Controversy: FG Constitutes Committee To Review New Minimum Wages For Workers

TUC President, Alex Osifo, in handshake with Ayo Fayose during the meeting While the meeting was chaired by the Secretary to the Government of the Federation (SGF), Senator George Akume, the TUC delegation was led by the President, Comrade Engr. The composition of the High-Powered Committee includes three representatives from the TUC, led by the Secretary-General, Office of the Secretary to the Government of the Federation (OSGF), Permanent Secretary, Office of the Head of the Civil Service of the Federation (OHCSF), National Salaries, Incomes and Wages Commission, and the Federal Ministry of…

Read →
COP31: EPIC joins calls for doubling of clean air funding for Africa, Asia and Latin America
health

COP31: EPIC joins calls for doubling of clean air funding for Africa, Asia and Latin America

The University of Chicago’s EPIC Air Quality Fund has called on philanthropic funders to double their annual support for clean air initiatives in Africa, Latin America and parts of Asia to about US$16 million by the next United Nations climate summit. The three regions, excluding China and India, currently receive a combined US$8.3 million annually for philanthropic air quality work, according to Christa Hasenkopf, Director of the Clean Air Program and founder of the EPIC Air Quality Fund.

Read →
Dangote’s bold Agri-Push signals a new era for West African trade – Borderless Alliance President
business

Dangote’s bold Agri-Push signals a new era for West African trade – Borderless Alliance President

Africa’s richest man, Aliko Dangote, has set his sights on transforming Ghana’s agricultural sector with massive investments in sugar, cocoa, and rice processing—a move that regional trade advocate Ziad Hamoui believes could finally shift West Africa away from exporting raw commodities toward building integrated regional value chains. Speaking to Blessed Sogah on JoyNews’ Connect Africa evening show on Monday, Hamoui, the National President of Borderless Alliance Ghana, unpacked the sweeping announcements made earlier in the day by Dangote and President John Dramani Mahama at the Invest Ghana…

Read →
Why I will vote for Tinubu in 2027 – Pinnick
politics

Why I will vote for Tinubu in 2027 – Pinnick

By Adegboyega Adeleye Former Nigeria Football Federation (NFF) president and Deputy Chairperson, FIFA Men’s National Teams Competition Committee Amaju Pinnick says he will vote for President Bola Tinubu in the 2027 election, citing what he described as improved sports administration and his desire to see Nigeria remain united. Pinnick, who is the deputy chairperson of the FIFA Men’s National Teams Competition Committee, said his support for Tinubu was based partly on the administration’s sports appointments and partly on the First Lady’s Itsekiri connection.

Read →