politics

Hoping for Britain to rejoin the EU with Andy Burnham? You may be waiting a long time

Hoping for Britain to rejoin the EU with Andy Burnham? You may be waiting a long time

Hoping for Britain to rejoin the EU with Andy Burnham? Measured against these great expectations, Burnham’s first big speech on Britain and Europe, delivered on Monday evening amid all the pomp and circumstance the City of London could furnish, must be considered a disappointment.

The PM’s first big speech on the UK and Europe was cautious and disappointing. Don’t expect any great leaps towards a new deal

Ever since Andy Burnham became the British prime minister this summer, people all over Europe have been asking me one question: “Will the UK rejoin the EU?” Sometimes they add: “And if so, when?” None of the intermediate options between the current hard Brexit and Brejoin are of any interest at all to most other Europeans.

Measured against these great expectations, Burnham’s first big speech on Britain and Europe, delivered on Monday evening amid all the pomp and circumstance the City of London could furnish, must be considered a disappointment. It was both a cautious and a curiously old-fashioned speech.

Cautious in diagnosis: his bold statement that “we have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years” was immediately followed by “the hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain”. (So a soft Brexit would be fine?) Cautious in prescription: beyond the welcome modest steps to be agreed at this Friday’s UK-EU summit (easier access for food and agricultural products, linking our carbon emissions markets, creating a youth mobility scheme), anything this government does during the term of the current parliament will stay within Keir Starmer’s “red lines” (no rejoining the customs union, single market or freedom of movement). Burnham will, however, explore “options for our long-term relationship” with the EU, “to inform decisions in the next parliament”. Unless we have an early election, that means not before 2029.

This caution is easily explained. Roughly half of his cabinet doesn’t want even to mention Brexit. Roughly half of his MPs are in constituencies that voted leave in 2016. The country at large thinks Brexit was a mistake but dreads the prospect of rerunning the debate and isn’t sure it would vote for rejoining if the UK didn’t have its previous opt-outs, including from the euro and the Schengen free travel area. For all the great expectations that were raised, Burnham himself had actually only said in interviews that he hoped Britain would rejoin the EU in his lifetime. He’s a robust 56-year-old, so that could take us to about 2060.

More surprising was how old-fashioned his speech was, albeit delivered with demotic verve. Here, for starters, was the weary old trope of Britain always having to “lead” in whatever it does (nine references to leading, if my count is correct). Then there’s the curious way in which Britain’s commitment to European defence and support for Ukraine is totally divorced from all the other dimensions of European security and strength, which self-evidently involve the EU. Instead, there’s a relentless narrow focus on what’s good for Britain economically. At the heart of his speech was what he called the “Makerfield test” – that is, what would deliver economic benefits for the hard-pressed people of his constituency of Makerfield, which in 2016 voted to leave the EU.

Oddest of all was the way he harked back to a 1948 speech in which Winston Churchill conjured Britain’s position at the intersection of three majestic circles. Gliding over the fact that the first circle Churchill mentioned was “the British Commonwealth and Empire”, Burnham talked at some length about the Commonwealth before coming to Europe. For obvious reasons (don’t offend the egomaniac in the White House!), he also glided over the fact that Churchill’s second circle was “the English-speaking world”, with its superpower being the US. Yet if we are highlighting, as Burnham did, how the world has changed since 2016, then the drastic change under Donald Trump in the US approach to its allies, including Britain, should be top of the list. Oh, and by the way, Churchill’s third circle was “United Europe”, which he talked of in visionary terms long before it ever existed. Now, with something called the European Union, much of Europe is at least halfway there.

Unlike in Churchill’s speech, in fact unlike in everything that great British and European leader said and did, here there was no sense of a wider European story in which Britain has always played an important part. Instead, Burnham spoke of Britain’s reset “with Europe”, as though Britain were not part of Europe and “Europe” only means the EU. The most European things in London’s Guildhall on Monday evening were the Polish vodka served by the Polish-South-African-British lord mayor of London, Bronek Masojada, and a few words in Dutch that he addressed to the prime minister’s wife, Marie-France van Heel.

But enough about the words. What of the actions to follow? I’m not sure how long these conversations with EU partners about “options” need to last. An hour or two might suffice. For the EU has repeatedly spelled out the current ones as it sees them. If you want a nice summary, look at the visual “staircase” of options prepared by the now sadly closing UK in a Changing Europe thinktank. But don’t get me wrong: continuing to explore all options until the next British election is the right thing to do, not least for one simple reason. After Europe’s megacycle of elections in 2026/27, an EU with, say, President Marine Le Pen in France, a coalition of centre-right and far-right parties in Spain, hard-right governments in Poland and Italy, and the AfD making the political running in Germany, may be a very different proposition.

Rationally speaking, I have no doubt that it would be much better for both Britain and Europe were the UK still to be a full member of the EU. Britain has many strengths that Europe needs: most of its best universities, leading AI startups, financial services, creative industries, supposedly super spooks (even if they don’t all resemble Robert Pattinson as James Bond). But the politics on both sides of the Channel will make this very difficult to achieve.

Meanwhile, Burnham’s tentative reopening of the issue has already led to the launch of not one but two anti-Brejoin pressure groups, one called Stay Out and the other mysteriously named Enough Official. Backed by some of the surviving old Brexit warhorses, they are already claiming that to rejoin the EU would cost Britain £750m a week. As in a nightmare, one glimpses the prospect of Boris Johnson, Michael Gove, Jacob Rees-Mogg and – gawd help us – Liz Truss tottering, like a gaggle of the undead, out of a red battlebus on the side of which is blazoned “Rejoining the EU would steal £750m a week from the NHS”.

Silver-tongued Gove, the Artful Dodger of British politics, the Iago of Brexit, now warns us that any move towards rejoining would “commit the country to another decade of fractious negotiations”. But that’s what we’re in for anyway, because both Britain and the EU will keep changing and therefore the relationship between the UK and its largest trading partner will inevitably be the subject of constant, difficult negotiations. And guess who gave us this dreary prospect? Gove, Johnson and all that gang. For all the criticisms I have made of his first big, not very European speech about “Europe”, give me Burnham any day.

Timothy Garton Ash is a historian, political writer and Guardian columnist. His new book, Europe in 7½ Chapters, is out now

  • burnham
  • britain
  • andy
  • speech
  • europe
  • time
  • leap
  • deal

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Burnham says Brexit has dramatically diminished Britain’s global standing
politics

Burnham says Brexit has dramatically diminished Britain’s global standing

Prime minister signals Labour could drop its Brexit red lines in major foreign policy speech Britain’s global standing has diminished in the decade since Brexit, Andy Burnham has said, as he again signalled that Labour could drop its red lines on Europe in its next manifesto. In a foreign policy speech, Burnham said that after a major Brussels summit this week he would begin new discussions with the EU about options for “our long-term relationship”.

Read →
Alan Milburn urges Burnham to spend billions on ‘new deal’ for young people
business

Alan Milburn urges Burnham to spend billions on ‘new deal’ for young people

Report on Britain’s youth jobs crisis calls for welfare, education, health and employment policy shake-up Andy Burnham is being urged to spend billions of pounds on a “new deal” for the next generation that would fund guaranteed jobs support for young people to offset a radical cut in benefits. In a watershed report on Britain’s youth jobs crisis, Alan Milburn, the Tony Blair-era health secretary, said the country was at a “fork in the road” after a surge in the number of young people not in education, employment or training (Neet) to almost a million.

Read →
Invest in international rail services to boost UK-EU reset, Burnham urged
politics

Invest in international rail services to boost UK-EU reset, Burnham urged

Campaigners call for reopening of high-speed Eurostar stations and new infrastructure for London St Pancras Britain should throw its weight behind international rail services to reset the UK-EU relationship, transport campaigners have urged the prime minister. A coalition of groups has called on Andy Burnham to commit to reopening high-speed stations for Eurostar and other services in Kent, and to support new infrastructure for passengers at London St Pancras and for rail freight.

Read →
Ministers vow to create new welfare system for young people as they back Milburn report
politics

Ministers vow to create new welfare system for young people as they back Milburn report

Government promises spending cuts to pay for the proposals, described by prime minister as ‘watershed moment’ UK politics live – latest updates Neet ideas: what’s in Milburn’s report? Ministers have promised to create an entirely new welfare system for young people as they gave their backing to Alan Milburn’s 278-page report, promising spending cuts next year to help pay for his proposals and giving him a government role to push them through.

Read →
Ministers to end Palantir’s contract with NHS in England in 2029
politics

Ministers to end Palantir’s contract with NHS in England in 2029

DHSC to extend US tech firm’s contract for two more years to allow time to line up British companies to replace it Ministers will end the NHS’s contract with the controversial tech firm Palantir – but not until 2029, to allow time to line up British companies to replace it. The Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) has decided to extend Palantir’s contract to provide the federated data platform (FDP) – the software that links different healthcare providers – for two more years rather than exercise a break clause that would have let them axe it next spring.

Read →