crime

Pandemic-era ban on filling grant-in-aid posts in aided educational institutions not perpetual: Karnataka High Court

Pandemic-era ban on filling grant-in-aid posts in aided educational institutions not perpetual: Karnataka High Court

A view of the High Court of Karnataka.

The High Court of Karnataka has declared that the State government’s notification issued on June 10, 2020, in the backdrop of the economic hardship caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, cannot be interpreted as imposing a perpetual prohibition on filling vacancies through grant-in-aid in private aided educational institutions.

The court also said a communication issued in February 2023, imposing a prohibition on filling grant-in-aid vacancies that arose in aided institutions after December 31, 2015, should not, by itself, be treated as an independent government policy or statutory instrument imposing a blanket ban on filling such vacancies.

A Division Bench comprising Justice D.K. Singh and Justice H. Shanthi Bhushan observed that while Clause 2 of the 2020 notification expressly prohibited filling vacancies arising due to retirement, death, resignation or other reasons during the financial year 2020-21 because of the financial constraints caused by the pandemic, Clause 3, which stated that no fresh consent could be given for filling vacant posts, could not be construed as introducing an indefinite ban on recruitment.

The Bench passed the order while partly allowing an appeal filed by the State government against a December 8, 2023, order of a single judge on a petition filed by the Karnataka Rajya Anudanitha Shikshana Samsthegalu Okkuta.

The Bench pointed out that the notification, read as a whole, was issued in the context of the financial difficulties prevailing during the pandemic. It neither prescribed December 31, 2015, as a cut-off date for filling vacancies nor expressly imposed a permanent prohibition on recruitment in aided institutions.

However, the Bench clarified that Section 52(2) of the Karnataka Education Act, 1983, empowers the State government to sanction grant-in-aid or refuse it for good and sufficient reasons, but does not independently confer the power to impose a general prohibition on filling vacancies in aided educational institutions.

The Bench also made it clear that its findings did not mean that every vacancy arising after December 31, 2015, must be filled or that the State was bound to sanction grant-in-aid for every such vacancy.

The State government could formulate an appropriate policy governing grant-in-aid, taking into account its financial capacity, provided it was consistent with the Act and the Rules. The Bench said the 2023 restriction was issued without any lawful basis.

The competent authority, the Bench said, on receipt of a request to fill grant-in-aid vacancies, has to examine applications from individual aided institutions independently, taking into account sanctioned strength, the nature and date of vacancies, existing teaching strength, student strength, staffing pattern, reservation requirements and financial implications.

The Bench also made it clear that prior permission from the government for filling grant-in-aid vacancies remains mandatory and that private aided institutions cannot proceed with recruitment without obtaining it. It set aside the single judge’s order to the extent that it had treated prior permission as a mere requirement of intimation and confined the competent authority’s scrutiny to compliance with the reservation roster.

  • ban
  • karnataka
  • high
  • court
  • era
  • grant
  • aid
  • post

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Wontumi’s lawyer to appeal High Court’s refusal to release prosecution deal with key witness
crime

Wontumi’s lawyer to appeal High Court’s refusal to release prosecution deal with key witness

Lawyer for former Ashanti Regional New Patriotic Party (NPP) Chairman Bernard Antwi-Boasiako, popularly known as Chairman Wontumi, Samuel Atta Akyea, says he is considering an appeal against a High Court ruling refusing to compel the prosecution to disclose its agreement with the first prosecution witness in the Tano Nimiri illegal mining case. The Accra High Court dismissed an application by Wontumi’s legal team seeking disclosure of the agreement between the prosecution and Edward Akuoko, Wontumi’s former manager, who has become the first prosecution witness in the case.

Read →