What stops us building the houses Britain needs

Emeritus professor Simon Price, Smart Growth UK’s Jon Reeds and former Labour council leader Steve Siddon respond to a column by John Harris John Harris points out the utter inadequacy of Labour’s housing plans, despite Andy Burnham’s passionate advocacy for new social housing (Is Burnham’s plan for a housing revolution anything more than a pipedream?, 15 November). The explanation is the future debt target.
Emeritus professor Simon Price, Smart Growth UK’s Jon Reeds and former Labour council leader Steve Siddon respond to a column by John Harris
John Harris points out the utter inadequacy of Labour’s housing plans, despite Andy Burnham’s passionate advocacy for new social housing (Is Burnham’s plan for a housing revolution anything more than a pipedream?, 15 November). And everyone agrees that we need many more houses. So what’s holding us back?
The problem lies in the fiscal rules. At first sight this is puzzling, as borrowing to invest is explicitly allowed (as opposed to borrowing to cover current expenditure). The explanation is the future debt target. Any capital investment increases public debt, and there is a binding debt-to-GDP ratio at the arbitrary and relatively close forecast horizon.
If you have a ceiling to taxation, this sort of makes sense. When you, for example, build a hospital, this has ongoing benefits and may well raise growth, but it also generates costs like salaries that have to come from somewhere, not to mention the debt service. It’s still true that if a project is worth doing, it should be done (and funded), but higher taxes are unpopular and the rule is there, and it seems we’re stuck with it.
But with housing, you get not only social benefits but also rent income that will pay for the investment, so this argument collapses. Debt that funds any investment that yields a financial return should be put in a separate accounting category and removed from the debt target. Let’s start with housing. Simon Price Emeritus professor of finance, Essex Business School
John Harris is right that building 1.5m new homes in the course of this parliament is a fantasy, but those of us campaigning to protect the planning system have always known that it was.
The 300,000 annual target was based on no assessment of need or capacity, let alone willingness to build. It stemmed from a 2015 House of Lords committee in need of a catchy headline that recommended raising it from 200,000. Housebuilders loved it because they knew they could persuade both Conservative and Labour governments to do more and more damage to the planning system in pursuit of it.
In reality, builders have no intention of chasing fantasy housing targets that apply both where and when markets are strong and where and when they’re not. And why would they bother trying to fulfil the Treasury’s 25-year dream of building so many homes that prices fall and iron out the ups and downs of the UK economy? Lower prices mean lower profits; a right to demand a 20% rate of return is one of many “reforms” they persuaded gullible ministers to include in planning guidance.
The latest victim is England’s green belts, where Labour has now allowed builders to demand huge chunks be recategorised as “grey belt”, though “cowpat estate belt” would be a better description. Jon Reeds Smart Growth UK
Following John Harris’s article regarding meeting social housing targets, and speaking as a retired Labour council leader, isn’t one of the solutions staring us in the face?
Allow councils to borrow money from the Public Works Loan Board at a reasonable interest rate to buy up housing currently for sale at the lower end of the market and rent it out to families on the housing waiting list.
This could have the benefit of creating instant council housing and, with that, cohesive communities, kickstart the private house-selling market and avoid the potential “stigma” of living on a council estate. It would also be self-funding. Steve Siddons Scarborough, North Yorkshire
- housing
- debt
- house
- britain
- labour
- john
- harris
- plan





