Blaming Ofsted inspectors for the system is unfair

Inspectors and educators alike have been placed under even greater pressure year after year, says Helen Kenny As national officer for the FDA, the union representing a large number of His Majesty’s Inspectors (HMIs), I read Simon Jenkins’ piece with great interest (Ofsted’s menacing inspections are still disastrous. Jenkins does at least suggest an alternative approach, unlike some who are calling for the abolition of Ofsted, but I really question whether he has thought it through.
Inspectors and educators alike have been placed under even greater pressure year after year, says Helen Kenny
As national officer for the FDA, the union representing a large number of His Majesty’s Inspectors (HMIs), I read Simon Jenkins’ piece with great interest (Ofsted’s menacing inspections are still disastrous. Schools should answer to the communities they serve, 13 November). Jenkins dismisses the work of HMIs as merely a “sniff” of the air and a stroll back to Whitehall, showing a lack of knowledge about their role. HMIs are former school leaders, with a deep knowledge and dedication to educating children and young people. They are as far from the typical civil servant (if there is such a thing) that it is possible to get, and in any case are not based in Whitehall.
Jenkins does at least suggest an alternative approach, unlike some who are calling for the abolition of Ofsted, but I really question whether he has thought it through. Parents value the provision of inspection, and most educators agree that assessments are fair – independent YouGov polling showed that 74% of educators believed their most recent inspection was accurate.
While an internal FDA survey of our HMI members shows that there have been improvements with the new inspection framework, could the process be better? Yes, further reform and resources are needed, as HMIs and educators alike have been placed under even greater pressure year after year, which has been evidenced through our own recent survey. But blaming the inspectors for the system is wholly unfair. They do not set government policy, but have an obligation to implement it, and ensure the quality of education expected by parents and pupils alike. Helen Kenny FDA national officer for Ofsted
- ofsted
- educator
- jenkins
- inspection
- inspector
- system
- inspectors
- hmis





