business

Early data suggests transparent auction pricing is working

Early data suggests transparent auction pricing is working

After a radical law change publishing "reserve" prices, the first month of data shows sale prices are close to what was advertised.

Analysis of 2,164 residential auctions in Victoria between October 16 and November 14 shows properties are selling for close to the published reserve prices.

NSW recently scrapped underquoting reforms, as the property market downturn leads some sellers to lower their price expectations.

Analysts say longer-term data is needed to determine the success of the Victorian reforms.

A closely watched change to real estate laws appears to be working to reduce underquoting and help buyers know what a property will sell for, based on early data.

Home sellers in Victoria must now publish the price they are willing to sell at — the "reserve" price — a week before an auction.

Property platform Homer has compiled the data for the first month since the practice became law in Victoria, for sales from October 16.

"The short version is yes, the data does suggest transparency is working," Homer chief executive Henry Pedersen told ABC News.

Mr Pedersen said properties that sold at auction went for a median of 0.9 per cent above the published reserve price.

Sellers in the state were already required to supply a price "range" of no more than 10 per cent, for example, between $600,000 and $660,000.

After examining 2,164 residential auctions between October 16 and November 14, more than three-quarters of homes sold had a reserve within that range.

Properties that had a reserve above the range were passed in at a higher rate (50 per cent) than those within the range (41 per cent).

"The data points one way," Mr Pedersen said.

"A guide that matches the reserve gives a home its best chance of selling on the day."

Independent property economist Cameron Kusher welcomed the data, but cautioned that longer-term analysis would be needed.

"It's hard to read too much into five weeks of data, in a down market, but it's about what you'd expect," he told ABC News

"A reserve price, within a guide [range] is more likely to be successful if it's within or below."

What complicates the discussion is the lower level of properties currently being offered for sale.

With prices falling, sellers who can wait to sell appear to be doing so.

"People are being a lot more selective about what they're taking to auction," he notes.

"People with more urgency to sell are the ones taking things to auction right now. They know the price they want and they're being transparent about that".

The shift in Victoria is being keenly watched nationwide, as governments grapple with frustrated buyers missing out on homes they never really had a chance at.

Underquoting happens when a property is advertised below the actual price that a real estate agent expects it to sell for, or below the price the seller would accept.

It's frustrating for buyers, who spend time and money — in building reports and inspections — on houses and units they were never going to be able to secure.

But it is difficult to legislate against.

The highly individual nature of property sales means it is difficult to estimate interest and demand to a high degree of accuracy.

The New South Wales government just scrapped laws to target underquoting because of the falling market.

Under the NSW reforms, agents could be banned from advertising a price that was lower than a written offer rejected by the seller — but that could be problematic in an environment where properties are not worth what they were valued at some months ago, and sellers may have to lower their expectations.

"It's not the seller or the agent's fault if the price of real estate is dropping," NSW Premier Chris Minns said.

Price falls were a factor in Victoria too, where the first month of the data has coincided with a cooling market.

Real estate agents who spoke at the time of the law change expected more sellers to opt for a "private sale" without a set date, because those sales do not have to publish a reserve price.

But for now, the Victorian experiment may be working, with more homes selling for what they are advertised: with the range or guide published ahead of the sale, and near the reserve price published a week before it.

"Three in four reserves now sit inside the guide," Mr Pedersen said after reviewing the data.

"Reserves above [the advertised range] have gone from about one in five to about one in seven."

  • datum
  • auction
  • pricing
  • price
  • law
  • change
  • reserve
  • month

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Kenya, EU move closer to landmark data protection agreement
business

Kenya, EU move closer to landmark data protection agreement

NAIROBI, Kenya, Nov 17 – Kenya is poised to unlock new investment opportunities in digital services and Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) following the conclusion of data protection adequacy negotiations with the European Union. The negotiations, which began in 2024, were conducted between the European Commission’s Directorate-General for Democracy, Justice, the Rule of Law and Consumer Protection and Kenya’s Office of the Data Protection Commissioner.

Read →
BoG confidence surveys showed mixed sentiments
business

BoG confidence surveys showed mixed sentiments

The October 2026 Bank of Ghana confidence surveys showed mixed sentiments. The Bank of Ghana’s core inflation measure, which excludes energy and utility prices, rose to 5.2% in October from 5.0% in September 2025.

Read →
Germany To Cut Electricity Tax, Cap Fuel Prices
business

Germany To Cut Electricity Tax, Cap Fuel Prices

Germany said Wednesday that it would cut electricity taxes and introduce a temporary fuel price cap to help households and businesses struggling with the energy shock sparked by the US war against Iran. Like elsewhere, energy costs have surged in Germany since the outbreak of the US-Israeli war against Iran and its disruptions to oil and gas shipments through the Strait of Hormuz.

Read →