crime

'Wounded pride' drove Lamarre-Condon to murder 'in cold blood', jury told

'Wounded pride' drove Lamarre-Condon to murder 'in cold blood', jury told

The Crown prosecutor says the jury could convict the accused of murder "on the strength of the forensic and ballistic evidence alone".

The Crown prosecutor has begun summing up his case in the Beau Lamarrre-Condon double murder trial.

Brett Hatfield SC said the jury could convict the accused of murder "on the strength of the forensic and ballistic evidence alone".

Mr Hatfield said Mr Lamarre-Condon's relationship with Jesse Baird was more casual than he had made out.

Former police officer Beau Lamarre-Condon's "wounded pride" drove him to a "darker plan for revenge" before he allegedly murdered Jesse Baird and Luke Davies "in cold blood", a jury has been told.

Crown Prosecutor Brett Hatfield SC told jurors in his closing address that they may consider they could "confidently convict the accused of the two counts of murder on the strength of the forensic and ballistic evidence alone".

Mr Hatfield has begun setting out what he says are the reasons why the panel could be satisfied of Mr Lamarre-Condon's guilt beyond reasonable doubt, saying that they might think the evidence shows an "obsession" with Mr Baird "led to these brazen and shocking murders".

Mr Lamarre-Condon, 31, denies two counts of murder over the deaths on February 19, 2024, when he says he went to Mr Baird's Paddington share house to retrieve possessions following their casual involvement with one another in parts of 2023.

He has told the jury from the witness box that he used his service pistol in self-defence after a struggle with Mr Baird, who was holding a knife in the kitchen and did not recognise him because he was dressed as an Uber Eats driver in a helmet.

He has further testified there was a second struggle with Mr Davies, who he said must have picked up the gun, and that as he attempted to pivot the weapon away from himself Mr Davies accidentally shot himself.

Mr Hatfield told the jurors they might think Mr Lamarre-Condon's account of a struggle with Mr Baird in the kitchen was "fanciful in the extreme".

On the Crown's case, Mr Baird was allegedly shot as he was "fleeing" for the back door and a second shot was an "execution"-style shot at a near-vertical angle.

"Luke Davies must have heard those first two shots," Mr Hatfield said.

"He must have realised, at the very least, something was seriously amiss in that house."

The prosecutor said Mr Davies must have either come out of the bedroom or only managed to shield himself behind the bedroom door, but alleged there could be "no doubt" he was killed by a shot which passed through the door.

"In this closing address, I'm going to set out many reasons why you would be clearly satisfied, beyond reasonable doubt, that the accused murdered both men in cold blood," Mr Hatfield said.

He said Mr Lamarre-Condon's account of the deaths was "a story put together afterwards to explain away two deliberate killings".

"When you put the accused's account aside, nothing in the evidence suggests self-defence or accident," he said.

In his evidence, Mr Lamarre-Condon previously told the Supreme Court that in early 2023 he was in a romantic, non-exclusive relationship with Mr Baird, which was ended about April that year.

But Mr Hatfield on Thursday said jurors might think that it "did not really move beyond something quite causal and was not anywhere near what the accused wanted it to be or made it out to be".

The Crown said Mr Lamarre-Condon allegedly engaged in stalking, tracking Mr Baird, and broke into his home in August 2023, before he managed to briefly re-establish an intimate relationship with Mr Baird.

The jury previously heard Mr Baird had requested no further contact in November that year, after discovering the accused had gone through his phone, blocked a man he had been spending time with, and then lied about it.

Mr Hatfield said Mr Lamarre-Condon had also "gaslighted" and sought to "manipulate Mr Baird and even his own friends", but when that failed, he began "lashing out at Mr Baird, first in words and then by conduct".

"Clearly, he wanted to harm Mr Baird," the prosecutor said.

He referred to evidence from a childhood friend of the accused, who recalled a November conversation in which Mr Lamarre-Condon allegedly tried to get a gun.

"His wounded pride had driven him to a darker plan for revenge, which ultimately led him to enter [the house] with his police Glock disguised as an Uber Eats driver on the morning of the 19th of February, 2024."

Mr Lamarre-Condon's evidence was that he went to Mr Baird's share house to retrieve a surfboard, an expensive ring, and clothing.

He previously told the jury that he dressed up as an Uber Eats driver in case Mr Baird was home because he wanted to avoid allegations of harassment and a potential AVO.

The bodies of Mr Baird and Mr Davies were found in surfboard bags in rural Bungonia just over a week after they died, and after Mr Lamarre-Condon had handed himself in to detectives.

He does not deny attempting, unsuccessfully, to sink the men's bodies in a dam in the area.

Mr Hatfield has foreshadowed his closing address may take two days.

  • jury
  • murder
  • pride
  • lamarre
  • condon
  • blood
  • crown
  • prosecutor

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Regina Re’s daughter to face murder charge as actress faces accessory charge
crime

Regina Re’s daughter to face murder charge as actress faces accessory charge

NAIROBI, Kenya, Nov 17 — The daughter of former television presenter and actress Regina Re is set to face a murder charge over the death of her 86-year-old grandmother, Dorita Lasinder Macharia, while her mother and brother will be charged with being accessories after the fact to murder. The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) confirmed on Tuesday, November 17, that it had approved charges against Thandie Malaika Wanjiku Gitao, Regina Wambui Macharia Gitao, popularly known as Regina Re, and Alton Jimmy Macharia.

Read →
Member of anti-migrant group found guilty of Staffordshire murder
crime

Member of anti-migrant group found guilty of Staffordshire murder

Raise the Colours activist Billy Allison, 36, killed man in ‘completely unprovoked and unjustified’ attack, say police A member of anti-migrant group Raise the Colours has been found guilty of murdering a man in a “completely unprovoked and unjustified” attack. Billy Allison, 36, delivered a “very, very hard” punch with the “stance and skill of an experienced fighter” which killed 44-year-old Matthew O’Gara while he was on a night out in Lichfield on 24 May.

Read →
Regina Re, brother freed on Sh200,000 bail over mother’s murder
crime

Regina Re, brother freed on Sh200,000 bail over mother’s murder

NAIROBI, Kenya, Nov 18 — Former television presenter and actress Regina Re and her brother Antony Macharia have been released on Sh200,000 cash bail each after pleading not guilty to charges of being accessories to the murder of their 86-year-old mother, Dorita Lasinder Macharia. Regina, whose full name is Regina Wambui Macharia Gitao, and her brother are accused of interfering with the crime scene to conceal evidence and cover up the alleged involvement of Regina’s daughter, Thandie Malaika Wanjiku Gitao.

Read →