politics

One Nation candidate's migrant welfare graph completely wrong, researcher says

One Nation candidate's migrant welfare graph completely wrong, researcher says

One Nation candidate Katherine Deves has used a graph depicting Australian welfare rates by country of birth to argue for deep cuts to migration, but a leading researcher says it

One Nation candidate Katherine Deves used a graph showing welfare rates to argue for deep cuts to migration.

ANU social policy expert Peter Whiteford says the chart is "completely wrong".

Ms Deves is running for the NSW upper house at the state election in March.

A leading researcher has rubbished a graph posted by NSW One Nation upper house candidate Katherine Deves that depicts high rates of welfare use among some migrant groups.

Peter Whiteford, the director of the Social Policy Institute at the Australian National University, told 702 ABC Sydney Mornings the graph was "very misleading" and its figures were "completely wrong".

Ms Deves, a lawyer and anti-transgender activist, ran unsuccessfully as a Liberal Party candidate for the seat of Warringah in the 2022 federal election, before leaving the party to join One Nation earlier this year.

She was announced as One Nation's candidate for the NSW Legislative Council on Sunday.

In an interview with Hamish Macdonald on 702 ABC Sydney Mornings on Wednesday, Ms Deves claimed a high rate of migrants receiving welfare payments was a reason to drastically reduce migration to Australia.

"When you look at some of the cohorts of people that have come from overseas, some of them are — up to a quarter of them are — on welfare compared to the Australian … I believe that they're Middle Eastern communities and it's up to 24 per cent," she said.

"We have concerns for the pressure being put on the NDIS, on health, education, on housing."

One Nation later said the source of the claim was a graph, which Ms Deves went on to post on her social media. It shows working-age welfare rates in Australia by country of birth, excluding the aged pension.

According to the graph, the highest rates of welfare recipients in Australia are people born in Sudan, Iraq and Syria.

It cites Department of Social Services and Bureau of Statistics longitudinal data sets as its source. However, it does not explain the methodology used to determine the figures shown in the graph.

Professor Whiteford said that most of the numbers in the chart were "puzzling to say the least".

During the interview Ms Deves also threw her support behind fellow NSW One Nation candidate Stuart Bonds, who told an anti-immigration rally earlier this month that white Australians were being "demographically replaced".

Those comments were widely condemned for being an apparent reference to the "great replacement theory" — a far-right conspiracy theory that claims white populations in Western countries are being deliberately replaced by immigrants from ethnic minorities.

"This is not a conspiracy theory, Hamish," Ms Deves said.

"We have a third of people currently in Australia who were born overseas. We have over half of Australians where they have one parent born overseas.

"So we are having mass, rapid, uncontrolled immigration in this country, the likes of which have never been seen before."

New South Wales Premier Chris Minns said Ms Deves's comments were "horrifying".

"Middle Eastern Australians or anyone who's come here have contributed a lot to New South Wales," he told reporters on Wednesday.

"They've started families, they've built businesses, they've joined communities. They're proud Australians.

"To see someone who isn't even elected decide that she's going to demonise them in order to get herself elected to the New South Wales parliament, I think it's not the kind of politics we need in Australia."

  • nation
  • welfare
  • graph
  • researcher
  • candidate
  • katherine
  • deves
  • rate

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Sifuna dismisses Ruto’s fourth State of the Nation Address as ‘State of Imagination’
politics

Sifuna dismisses Ruto’s fourth State of the Nation Address as ‘State of Imagination’

NAIROBI, Kenya, Nov 18 – Linda Mwananchi Party leader Edwin Sifuna has criticised President William Ruto’s fourth State of the Nation Address, accusing him of failing to address the constitutional requirements of the annual presidential report and instead focusing on development projects. “So ever since I was elected, I said that because Kasongo’s (President Ruto) work is to lie about those things of his, I don’t attend that State of the Nation address ,someone said it’s called the ‘State of Imagination’, right?

Read →
Two Clocks, One Election
politics

Two Clocks, One Election

November 23: Cooperation Acquires a Date The Coalition for Democracy says participating opposition parties will meet at the NAF Conference Centre in Abuja on Monday, November 23. The proposed business includes a National Covenant for Democratic Renewal, a Framework for Opposition Unity and a National Reform Programme.

Read →
2027: Reject corrupt candidates, end imposition, Maho tells parties
politics

2027: Reject corrupt candidates, end imposition, Maho tells parties

By Favour Ulebor, Abuja Ahead of the 2027 general elections, political analyst and lecturer at the International Institute of Journalists, Dr Austin Maho, has urged political parties to reject corrupt candidates, end the imposition of party leaders and introduce strict disciplinary measures to strengthen Nigeria’s democracy. Maho made the call on Wednesday in Abuja at the International Stakeholders Engagement Forum on Anti-Corruption, Party Building and Democratic Governance, organised by the Diplomatic Correspondents Association of Nigeria (DICAN).

Read →
2027: SDP pledges free education, vows to tackle insecurity
politics

2027: SDP pledges free education, vows to tackle insecurity

Speaking on Wednesday at the SDP presidential campaign rally in Yola, Adamawa State, the party’s National Chairman, Professor Sadiq Gombe, urged Nigerians to make informed political choices ahead of the 2027 elections, saying poverty and insecurity required purposeful leadership and people-oriented policies. In his remarks, the presidential candidate, Adebayo, said an SDP-led administration would redefine governance by ensuring that public resources were deployed for the benefit of Nigerians, with priority given to security, education, healthcare, housing, food security and employment.

Read →