politics

Government questions previous Supreme Court orders on nationwide enquiry into private universities

Government questions previous Supreme Court orders on nationwide enquiry into private universities

The Justice Amanullah Bench had sought a full disclosure of benefits granted by the Centre and States, including the terms of allotment of land and preferential treatment, on these private institutions

Representational image.

Following a change in the Supreme Court Bench, the Union government on Thursday (November 19, 2026) urged the new combination of judges to reconsider their colleagues’ earlier orders which transformed an individual grievance of a private university student into a nationwide judicial enquiry into the circumstances of setting up, regulation, functioning and concessions granted to private universities.

The case concerns a writ petition filed in 2025 by a student, Ayesh Jain, against Amity University.

Ms. Jain has alleged the university refused her request for a change of name in its rolls even though she had produced the required documents. She accused the university of harassment and taunts for changing her first name from a traditionally Hindu sounding ‘Khushi’ to ‘Ayesha’. She had alleged that the university barred her from attending classes.

The case was heard extensively by an apex court Bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah for several months.

Besides setting up a committee to look into whether Ms. Jain’s allegations revealed any criminal offence or civil wrongs, the Bench had expanded the scope of the petition, from a mere individual grievance, to a sweeping examination into the functioning of private universities across the country.

In a recent development, the case was shifted from Justice Amanullah’s Bench, despite the fact that the case had been heard substantially. The petition was allocated to a three-judge Bench headed by Justice Vikram Nath, the senior most puisne judge of the Supreme Court.

A fresh hearing before the reconstituted Supreme Court Bench witnessed the government complain about the aftermath of the expanded adjudication ordered by the previous Bench.

For one, Additional Solicitor General K.M. Natraj, for the government, said States had to file “voluminous status reports of 40,000 pages each”.

Mr. Natraj indicated that judicial scrutiny must be confined to giving the student relief, if deserved, and not embark on a nationwide enquiry.

He questioned the apex court’s previous orders, subjecting States to the mandamus of looking into the functioning of “each and every private university” in their respective jurisdictions.

The government’s law officer specifically drew attention to the Justice Amanullah Bench’s order of November 2025.

This particular order had sought the details from the Centre and States on the background and provisions of laws leading to the establishment of all private, non-government and deemed-to-be universities. It had directed the Centre, States and the University Grants Commission to disclose steps taken to ensure that private universities make good their promise to function on a ‘no profit, no loss’ basis.

The Justice Amanullah Bench had sought a full disclosure of benefits granted by the Centre and States, including the terms of allotment of land and preferential treatment, on these private institutions.

The Justice Nath Bench agreed to look into the submissions made by the government. Meanwhile, the committee set up to enquire into Ms. Jain’s allegations was allowed time till December end to submit a final report.

  • government
  • supreme
  • court
  • enquiry
  • question
  • order
  • university
  • justice

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Falana urges FG to pursue £420m British reparations, withdraw appeal
politics

Falana urges FG to pursue £420m British reparations, withdraw appeal

Human rights lawyer, Femi Falana, SAN, has urged the Federal Government to mount diplomatic pressure on the British Government to pay £420 million in damages awarded by a Federal High Court to the families of 21 coal miners killed in the 1949 Iva Valley massacre in Enugu State. Falana also called on the Federal Government to withdraw its appeal against the judgment, arguing that the British Government had not challenged the historic decision.

Read →
2027 Election: Court Affirms Yahaya Bello As APC Senatorial Candidate For Kogi Central
politics

2027 Election: Court Affirms Yahaya Bello As APC Senatorial Candidate For Kogi Central

Justice Inyang Ekwo of the Federal High Court in Abuja has affirmed the former Governor of Kogi State, Yahaya Bello, as the APC Candidate for Kogi Senatorial. Delivering Judgement, Justice Ekwo dismissed the suit filed by Momoh Obaro challenging the emergence of former Kogi State Governor Yahaya Bello as winner of the May 2026 Kogi Central Senatorial District primary election.

Read →