science

‘Take temperature down’ over guidance on single-sex spaces, head of UK equalities body urges

‘Take temperature down’ over guidance on single-sex spaces, head of UK equalities body urges

EHRC chair says ‘misinformation’ about guidance issued after supreme court ruling has created ‘more anxiety’ The head of the UK’s equalities watchdog has urged people to “take the temperature down” on reaction to guidance issued on single-sex spaces. Mary-Ann Stephenson, the chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC), appearing before MSPs in Holyrood, said “misinformation” over the body’s guidance had created “more anxiety among people”.

EHRC chair says ‘misinformation’ about guidance issued after supreme court ruling has created ‘more anxiety’

The head of the UK’s equalities watchdog has urged people to “take the temperature down” on reaction to guidance issued on single-sex spaces.

Mary-Ann Stephenson, the chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC), appearing before MSPs in Holyrood, said “misinformation” over the body’s guidance had created “more anxiety among people”.

The guidance was released earlier this year after a ruling by the supreme court that sex in the Equality Act 2010 referred to biological sex.

The ruling has caused concern among transgender people in Scotland, with some choosing not to seek medical attention as a result, according to organisations who also appeared before the Scottish parliament’s equalities, human rights and civil justice committee on Thursday.

Stephenson told the committee: “It is really clear that there are significant numbers of trans people, including, particularly, maybe younger trans people, who feel very, very anxious at the moment and I think that some of that is to do with the fact that what they thought the law entitled them to, it turned out wasn’t the case.”

She added: “I think that some of this is about the way in which the code has been characterised and talked about in really inflated language. Saying that it excludes all trans people from public life, that there’s going to be genital checks to ensure people’s access to services. I can understand feelings are high, people are upset, but actually, it doesn’t help.

“What it does is create more anxiety among people about things that actually the law doesn’t say, the code doesn’t say, and I think it’s incumbent on all of us to try to take the temperature down a little bit in this area and to try to recognise that at the heart of the Equality Act is trying to build a society where everybody is able to live with dignity and have access to the services they need, not to face discrimination.”

The guidance has had an effect on various areas of life for transgender people, according to organisations who support them, including access to leisure facilities and healthcare settings.

Florence Oulds, the policy and public affairs coordinator at the charity Scottish Trans, told of cases in which people had refused to go to hospital.

“We are aware of at least three trans people we’ve spoken to and other trans people we’ve heard evidence from who have not gone to hospital, against medical advice, because they are concerned about where they’ll be placed on a ward,” she told MSPs. “I think that’s a very common sentiment.”

Oulds also claimed the guidance lacked clarity, saying the code of practice was “just fundamentally a very confusing and difficult document to follow”.

Oulds said the EHCR “often instructs organisations to seek legal advice but there does seem to be an unbelievably wide range of legal advice in this area, often completely conflicting. I have heard from organisations who are trans-inclusive, want to do the right thing, want to see if they can remain trans-inclusive while still remaining in the law, who have spent lots of money on legal advice and not really got anywhere.”

Stephenson said she “would disagree with that interpretation” and added: “I think the code is actually quite straightforward.”

  • guidance
  • temperature
  • head
  • body
  • equality
  • sex
  • space
  • chair

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Nasa’s Voyager 1 just reached a massive milestone in space - video
science

Nasa’s Voyager 1 just reached a massive milestone in space - video

Nasa sent the Voyager 1 and 2 probes into space almost 50 years ago to explore the outer reaches of our solar system. To find out more about its astonishing journey, Madeleine Finlay hears from Jim Bell, a planetary scientist and professor at Arizona State University’s school of Earth and space exploration.

Read →
‘The game is in danger’: PFA head Maheta Molango on Fifa, Infantino and football’s future
sports

‘The game is in danger’: PFA head Maheta Molango on Fifa, Infantino and football’s future

At a potentially critical juncture for football, the PFA chief executive talks about the organisation, wider fears in the game and why the Folarin Balogun affair was ‘scandalous’ After five years in charge of the Professional Footballers’ Association, what has Maheta Molango learned? “I’ve learned that the game I loved and led me to first play and then advise and then lead a club and today to lead the PFA, is in danger because it is being forgotten.”

Read →
BAE to slash 1,000 jobs across head office and air business to streamline orders
business

BAE to slash 1,000 jobs across head office and air business to streamline orders

Job cuts to exclude shop floor, aircraft maintenance and trainees but move prompts calls for more orders to support British defence giant BAE Systems has announced plans to cut more than 1,000 jobs from its workforce, triggering calls for ministers to place extra orders with Britain’s biggest defence contractor. The company said it is aiming to cut 1,070 jobs at its head office and air business in the UK, as it tries to meet customer demands for “greater speed and efficiency in getting critical capabilities into the hands of those who need them”.

Read →
The Altruists review – two of TV’s best actors light up this chaotic crypto tale
crime

The Altruists review – two of TV’s best actors light up this chaotic crypto tale

Julia Garner and Anthony Boyle play the FTX founders behind ‘the greatest fraud ever committed’ in the US. Welcome to The Altruists, a breakneck breakdown of the brief career of Sam Bankman-Fried (played by Anthony Boyle) who, with his on-off girlfriend Caroline Ellison (played by Julia Garner), set up the cryptocurrency exchange FTX with the belief that it would revolutionise finance and – as the increasingly absurd/dishonest/knowingly satirical Silicon Valley mantra has it – make the world a better place.

Read →
‘I hope paramedics are on standby for the sex scenes!’ The wet and wild TV experience leaving fans dizzy
lifestyle

‘I hope paramedics are on standby for the sex scenes!’ The wet and wild TV experience leaving fans dizzy

Like me, she has never been to a 4DX screening before – but when Cineworld announced it would be showing episodes five and six of queer hockey drama Heated Rivalry in the novel format, she booked tickets immediately. Over the last two weeks, Heated Rivalry fans have been treated to big screen marathons of Jacob Tierney’s hit TV show, based on Rachel Reid’s bestselling book series, Game Changers.

Read →