Law 'stacked' against child abuse victims after Qld reform blocked, lawyers say
The legislation would have allowed institutions that facilitated abuse to be held legally responsible, including churches and sporting clubs.
The Queensland government has blocked legislation that would have held institutions legally responsible for child sexual abuse.
Lawyers say the decision is "bitterly disappointing" and fails victims.
Attorney-General Deb Frecklington says the legislation would create "legal uncertainty".
The Queensland government has failed victims of child sexual abuse by voting down changes aimed at helping them seek justice, top lawyers say.
Legislation introduced by the Labor opposition would have allowed institutions that facilitated abuse, including churches, sporting clubs, and volunteer groups, to be held legally responsible.
It followed a 2024 High Court decision which found the Catholic Church wasn't vicariously liable for the actions of a paedophile priest because he was not formally an employee.
The government, with the balance of power in state parliament, voted against the legislation, citing that it would create legal uncertainty.
Maurice Blackburn's Queensland abuse law leader, Heather Kerley, said victims were now worse off than those interstate, where the loophole had been closed.
"The Queensland government says it stands with survivors. Then it slams the courtroom door in their faces. You can't do both," Ms Kerley said.
"Saying you're for victims while voting against them is standing up for victims with your fingers crossed behind your back.
"The law in Queensland is now stacked against every child who was abused or who, sadly, is experiencing abuse as we speak. It is stacked in a way it isn't in the ACT or Victoria."
Slater and Gordon Lawyers' head of abuse law, Stephanie Brown, said the High Court decision effectively meant institutions could wash their hands of responsibility.
She called on the government to find a way to close the loophole, labelling the failed legislation "bitterly disappointing".
"This common-sense reform would have made it very clear that organisations can be held to account for abuse committed on their watch," she said.
In a statement, Attorney-General Deb Frecklington did not answer questions on how the government might close the loophole and instead affirmed its focus on victims.
"The Crisafulli Government's commitment to victims is steadfast, and we acknowledge the pain and lifelong consequences suffered by victims and survivors of historical child sexual abuse and the courage it takes for people to come forward," she said.
"Labor has attempted to capitalise on a complex legal environment and propose legislation that risks legal uncertainty and unintended consequences, including exposing victims to protracted litigation."
Following Tuesday's vote on the legislation, shadow attorney-general Meaghan Scanlon said the government had railed against laws designed to give victims a fair chance to hold institutions to account.
"That is appalling, cruel, and shows that their support for victims is merely lip service," she said.
"If the LNP truly supported victims, they would have worked with us, supported these laws to give victims of child sexual abuse a voice and a pathway to justice.
"Victims of child sexual abuse deserve a voice, and they deserve a lot better than this government."
- abuse
- law
- child
- qld
- reform
- victim
- lawyer
- legislation



