While the headlines rave about Milburn’s Neets review, the young people I know are angry and frustrated

But young people just want a fairer jobs market Felicity Halstead is the founder and CEO of GoodWork, a London-based youth employment and social mobility charity Felicity Halstead is the founder and CEO of GoodWork, a London-based youth employment and social mobility charity Continue reading...
The focus seems to be on welfare reform as a way to deal with youth unemployment. But young people just want a fairer jobs market
Felicity Halstead is the founder and CEO of GoodWork, a London-based youth employment and social mobility charity
I was at my desk last Thursday morning as a steady stream of young people filed into GoodWork’s central London community hub for a day of employability workshops. Despite the accusations of disengagement among young people, they didn’t need me to tell them that proposals to cut some benefits for under-25s were all over the news. I could hear them talking about it as soon as the lift pinged open – and the mood was low.
Alan Milburn has made a concerted effort to say that he doesn’t believe young people are to blame for dire levels of youth unemployment. He says the system has let them down and only a decade-long transformation will fix a problem that is complex and deeply entrenched. Simply recognising the scale of the problem and being willing to invest in a solution is a positive start.
But what I’ve heard from young people is frustration that their struggles in the job market are framed primarily through a need to reform the welfare system. They hear a lot about their responsibilities and benefit entitlements, but less about what is being done to make the job market fairer.
Our employability programme focuses heavily on the art of getting work – helping young people from low-income backgrounds to navigate a system that is often stacked against them. Increasingly, finding a good job feels like a game in which they are repeatedly set up to lose.
In April, we worked with the Inside the Mind of a Young Neet report, commissioned by the Milburn review, to host a round table, bringing young people and employers together to discuss some of these issues. The picture was complicated. Young people wanted to know why employers aren’t offering more opportunities, and why they’re being “ghosted” and not given feedback on their applications. Employers talked about the rising cost of hiring, budget pressures, hundreds of AI-generated job applications, and organisational instructions to avoid giving any feedback out of fear that it may lead to litigation. This has all created a job market where entry level jobs are almost impossible to access without experience, traditional hiring practices have broken down and young talent is increasingly lost and confused.
So how does the Milburn review address this? My biggest hope was that it would set out how the government could create a labour market that offers opportunities at scale for young people. It goes some of the way, notably by proposing “opportunity” and “support” guarantees, which ensure every young person can get a college place, training, apprenticeship, high-quality work experience or a job. It could make a real difference – but it’s understandable that a lot of young people, who have been made to feel like a low political priority, have limited confidence in whether the government could deliver this for them.
Take Lucy, 22, who tells me that she “can’t afford to be Neet”. She wants to work in the creative industries but is stuck taking any work she can get because her family needs her to be earning. For young people like Lucy, there’s not much in the review to get excited about. The report opens by saying that “a young person’s future should depend on their aptitudes and aspirations not their background or their birth”. It does very little to make the possibility of a career – not just a job – a reality.
My fear is that the recommendations don’t go far enough or fast enough to create decent opportunities. Proposed cuts to employer national insurance contributions would be slow, and targeted initially at retail and hospitality, creating new vacancies but limiting choice. More apprenticeships are welcome but they won’t do much for the 15% of Neets who have a degree. The opportunity guarantee is promising at first glance. But I am sceptical of its “personalised participation plan”, as young people have told us that their experience of state-sponsored support into work doesn’t usually pay much attention to the sort of work they want to do.
For small- and medium-sized enterprises there needs to be clearer support for hiring young people. While hiring costs might be offset by the youth jobs grant, young people who have been Neet for more than six months are likely to need strong wraparound support, on-the-job training and pastoral care to make work placements a success. There are tentative measures that the report wants to “explore”, but I suspect it’ll be some time before we see an increase in hiring at scale.
Milburn’s report makes a lot of the “duty to engage” for young people. What’s missing is the same duty for employers. The “first chance” commitment outlined in the report makes sensible recommendations – creating more jobs, apprenticeships and work experience, and committing to giving feedback on applications. But it stops short of mandating employer action, meaning there is no clear framework for accountability if recruitment processes remain opaque, or young people are not offered meaningful work or opportunities for development.
There’s a disconnect between how the review positions itself as responsive to young people’s needs and how it’s actually being received by many young people. As I write this, our 23-year-old communications assistant, Manal, is scrolling through TikTok to gauge how young people are feeling about the headlines, which are overwhelmingly focused on welfare. “They’re angry,” she says. I’m not sure I blame them.
- people
- milburn
- youth
- goodwork
- london
- neets
- review
- unemployment




