crime

Judges, juries and rape myths in trials

Judges, juries and rape myths in trials

Paul Keleher KC offers an insight into how juries are directed. Plus a letter from Prof Nicole Moreham In your report (‘Pull back the curtain’ on treatment of sexual assault victims in court, says UK government adviser, 15 November), Prof Katrin Hohl suggests that while significant progress has been made by police forces and the Crown Prosecution Service, the court system was being left behind.

Paul Keleher KC offers an insight into how juries are directed. Plus a letter from Prof Nicole Moreham

In your report (‘Pull back the curtain’ on treatment of sexual assault victims in court, says UK government adviser, 15 November), Prof Katrin Hohl suggests that while significant progress has been made by police forces and the Crown Prosecution Service, the court system was being left behind.

It seems to be little known that for many years judges have been trained to direct juries to ignore rape myths and direct them that many victims of sexual assault are unable to physically resist and often delay reporting the assault. Juries are directed that this should not cast doubt on their accounts of being assaulted.

Examples of the full direction can be found in the published crown court compendium, which observes that “There is a possibility that juries will make and/or be invited by advocates to make unwarranted assumptions. It is important that the judge should alert the jury to guard against this.”

The court of appeal has stated that “We accept that the effect of each direction may be to bolster the evidence of a victim; but it only bolsters their evidence to the extent necessary to prevent unfairness to the victim caused by the stereotypical thinking against which it warns.”

This does not prevent the defence relying on this unattractive and out‑of-date tactic, but, given that the jury can receive these directions in writing to take into the jury room, it may well backfire if they do. Paul Keleher KC London

Gaby Hinsliff is right to ask questions about the role that the law is playing in keeping serious allegations of wrongdoing out of the public domain (Don’t just blame the culture for keeping powerful men’s dirty secrets. Blame the law too, 13 November). Many academics share her concerns.

While not perfect, the law of defamation contains free-speech protections that have been developed over centuries. They seek to strike a delicate balance between protecting individual reputation and allowing genuine allegations of serious wrongdoing to reach the public consciousness.

Like Hinsliff, numerous legal commentators have challenged the idea that powerful people should be able to dodge those free-speech protections by bringing actions in privacy, harassment or breach of confidence instead. Prof Nicole Moreham Co-editor, The Law of Privacy and the Media (fourth edition)

  • jury
  • rape
  • assault
  • judge
  • myth
  • prof
  • victim
  • court

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Judicial Service trains judges, court officials in ADR
crime

Judicial Service trains judges, court officials in ADR

The Judicial Service has trained selected judges, magistrates, court registrars and clerks in Court-Connected Alternative Dispute Resolution (CCADR) to strengthen the use of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms in the justice delivery system. The release said Justice Angelina Mensah-Homiah, a Justice of the Court of Appeal and Judge-in-Charge of ADR, facilitated the sessions.

Read →
Four UK men convicted of sexual assault and rape of woman at invitation of husband
crime

Four UK men convicted of sexual assault and rape of woman at invitation of husband

Former Tory councillor advertised ex-wife on swinging websites and drugged and bound her for sex Four men have been convicted of sexually assaulting and raping a woman at the invitation of her husband who had drugged and bound her. Philip Young, 50, advertised his then wife, Joanne Young, on dating and swinging websites, presenting it as a “kink” for both of them, Winchester crown court heard.

Read →
Gérard Depardieu and Michel Houellebecq investigated over on-set rape and assault allegations
entertainment

Gérard Depardieu and Michel Houellebecq investigated over on-set rape and assault allegations

Actor and author are alleged to have attacked and gang-raped a woman while filming together in 2018 French police are investigating allegations that the actor Gérard Depardieu and the author Michel Houellebecq gang-raped and assaulted a woman during a 2018 film shoot. The alleged attack took place in December 2018 during the shooting of Thalasso, a film starring the two men as versions of themselves who meet at a health spa and have long philosophical conversations while in white bath-robes.

Read →
Bring in ‘cosmetic cowboys’ law to avoid more deaths, says family of butt lift victim
health

Bring in ‘cosmetic cowboys’ law to avoid more deaths, says family of butt lift victim

Relatives speak out after inquest jury find Alice Webb’s death after filler entered her organs was accidental The family of a woman who died after a botched Brazilian butt lift have called for laws against “cosmetic cowboys” to be introduced before more people lose their lives. Speaking as an inquest jury concluded Alice Webb’s death was accidental, her family said they were astonished people were still having BBLs despite what had happened to her.

Read →