health

Consent under scrutiny: where does youth end and adulthood begin?

Consent under scrutiny: where does youth end and adulthood begin?

After the Brand and Walliams revelations, calls for a ‘staggered’ age of consent are redefining what makes someone ‘adult’ The fact that the age of sexual consent in Britain is set at 16 is thanks to a chimney sweep’s daughter from Marylebone, London, called Eliza Armstrong – not that she had any say in the matter. In June 1885, Armstrong had just turned 13 when she was sold for sex by her alcoholic mother for the sum of £5.

After the Brand and Walliams revelations, calls for a ‘staggered’ age of consent are redefining what makes someone ‘adult’

The fact that the age of sexual consent in Britain is set at 16 is thanks to a chimney sweep’s daughter from Marylebone, London, called Eliza Armstrong – not that she had any say in the matter.

In June 1885, Armstrong had just turned 13 when she was sold for sex by her alcoholic mother for the sum of £5. She believed she was going to work as a gentleman’s maid; instead, the child was taken to a brothel, where she was examined to prove she was a virgin and drugged with chloroform to await the gentleman who had “purchased” her virginity.

But this time, the man was not, in fact, planning to rape her. WT Stead was a crusading tabloid newspaper editor with an eye for titillation, intent on proving his contention that young girls were being widely sold by their parents for sexual exploitation on the streets of London.

The lurid, four-part exposé published in the Pall Mall Gazette – titled with characteristic Victorian bombast, the “Maiden Tribute of Modern Babylon” – caused an absolute sensation. Mobs rioted outside the newspaper’s offices trying to get hold of copies. A reported 250,000 people marched on Hyde Park demanding the age of consent, then set at 13 for girls, be raised to 16. By the end of 1885, parliament had been strong-armed into passing legislation – colloquially known as Stead’s act – setting an age boundary which, for heterosexual sex, has remained in place in most of the UK since.

More than 140 years later, pioneering journalism and sexual scandal have put the age of consent back on the agenda. The conviction and jailing of Russell Brand for rape and sexual assault, and the allegations of sexual misconduct and grooming against David Walliams, which he has denied, have drawn attention not only to abuse of power in the media, but to relationships in which very young people are having sex with much older adults.

The accusations against both entertainers – which came to light after lengthy newspaper and TV investigations, including by the Guardian – included revelations that Brand and Walliams had sexual relationships while in their 30s with girls of 16. It led to calls from campaigners and survivors to introduce a “staggered” age of consent, by which sex with 16- and 17-year-olds becomes illegal for adults more than four years older than them.

“I think we all agree that adults shouldn’t be allowed to have sexual relationships with children, with somebody under the age of 18,” said Mia Latter, who alleged she was raped by Brand when she was 16 and he was 30.

Layla Stone, a child protection social worker who leads the Close the Consent Gap campaign group, said those aged 16 and 18 were seen as children in “every single framework of the law”. “We don’t believe [they are] old enough to consent to having sex with much older adults,” she said.

Latter’s argument has forced a reckoning with a question that is, depending on how you look at it, a matter of legal and moral certainty, or of endless cultural variety: is there a right answer to the question of when children come of age?

Many 16- and 17-year-olds might bristle at being described as children, after all – and in some respects, that is understandable. They can join the armed forces in the UK, and in Scotland and Northern Ireland can marry with parental permission; in almost all US states they can drive a car; in Malta and Austria, they can vote in local and national elections; and they can get a tattoo without parental consent in the Netherlands. But in the US, neither they, nor anyone else under 21, can buy a can of beer.

The law on sexual consent is as good an example as any of this quandary, according to Laura Lammasniemi, an assistant professor of law at the University of Warwick, whose work has focused on the history of consent boundaries. “Often we think of age of consent as being related to physical maturity, but there’s clearly a very strong religious and political aspect to it as well,” she said.

In England and Wales, for instance, the 1885 law on consent at 16 applied only to unmarried girls; female children could marry at 12 until 1929, and inside marriage, their sexual acquiescence was taken for granted. That disparity, like other inconsistencies, was largely moralistic, said Lammasniemi. “If the sexual behaviour was somehow considered to be potentially harmful, you needed a higher age to consent to it than you did for something like marriage, which was considered to be generally a social good.”

A similar moralism meant the legal age of sex between gay men, even after it was partly decriminalised for those over 21 in 1967, wasn’t equalised until 2000 (lesbian sex, at whatever age, didn’t appear in English law until 2003). Northern Ireland, which had a more religious and conservative culture, raised the bar from 16 to 17 in 1950 until it was equalised with the rest of the UK in 2008.

Such disparities are replicated internationally, where the boundaries on sexual consent have varied to a surprising degree. Though additional clauses covering close-in-age relationships or authority figures often complicate the headline numbers, in Italy, Germany, Brazil and much of Central America, sex is permissible at 14. In France and Sweden it is 15, while in Ireland, Cyprus, South Australia and Texas, it is 17. Fourteen US states, including California and Florida, set the minimum age of consent at 18. Argentina permits sex in some circumstances from 13.

But if sex is very often “the first form of adulthood that you get to try out”, according to Rachel Thomson, a professor of childhood and youth studies at the University of Sussex, neither the age at which it becomes legal nor the age at which teenagers start actually doing it are very helpful in defining the transition to adulthood. She highlighted data showing that, while the age of first intercourse plummeted over the late 20th century, the gap until they had their first live-in relationship or first child – both traditional markers of becoming “grownups” – has dramatically widened since.

While young people have often been blamed for indulging in an extended adolescence, in which they have lived at home longer, settled into stable careers later and delayed forming their own committed relationships and families, such decisions are often beyond their individual control.

“There has been a real transformation of the scaffolding outside of the family that makes it possible to become autonomous and independent in the world,” said Thomson. The adult transition experienced by many in older generations – “the idea of leaving school at 16, being able to walk straight into a job, being able to set up home, to start a family in your 20s” – was largely obsolete, she noted. Some young people, particularly from disadvantaged backgrounds, may have found themselves catapulted into early adulthood. But life for many others has involved “yo-yo transitions, going backwards and forwards from home to independence, home to independence”.

“Adulting”, Thomson pointed out, has become a verb to younger generations: something tried out in the short term but difficult to complete. “Culturally and historically, [we are in] a new situation where young people are often swimming round around in circles rather than swimming forwards,” she said.

The extended process of growing up has at least tallied with the neuroscience of late adolescence, which has shown that the brain undergoes continuous development into the late 20s, leading some experts to argue that adolescence should be redefined to span the ages 10-24.

“There is no single age at which the human brain can be universally classified as ‘adult’, as neurodevelopment is a continuous process without sharp transition points, marked by substantial individual variation,” Sarah-Jayne Blakemore, a professor of psychology and cognitive neuroscience at the University of Cambridge, wrote in a recent paper on the developing adolescent brain.

The minimum age of criminal responsibility ranges from seven in some African and South Asian countries, to 18 in Brazil and Peru. England, Wales and Northern Ireland, and most Australian states, set that threshold at 10, and for federal crimes in the US it is 11.

In most of the world, 18 marks the most significant goalpost, after which children are treated as adults for most legal purposes and, usually, can vote. But even this milestone could be more arbitrary than it appears.

The age of universal suffrage, for instance, was not set at 18 anywhere until 1969, when the UK became the first democracy in the world to reduce the voting age from 21, a move rapidly copied by other nations. The decision by Harold Wilson’s Labour government, some academics have argued, was motivated not by a sense of 18 as the definitive age of adult responsibility, but by electoral concerns over their failure to attract younger members.

“This idea that we have this magic boundary at 18, that has never really existed,” said Christine Huebner, a lecturer in quantative social sciences at the University of Sheffield, whose work has focused on the transition from childhood to full citizenship and the impact of lowering the voting age to 16.

“And if you think about it, the rights that young people acquire are really staggered at different ages – and probably for good reason. You might argue, for instance, that making a life-changing decision about who to marry or whether or not to get a mortgage is more important than the decision of which party to vote for in a certain election,” she said.

For one recent piece of work, Huebner followed a group of young adults between the ages of 15 and 21 and asked them periodically how adult they felt at different stages, and why. “There were funny little things they mentioned. Donating blood [permissible in the UK at 17] was a big thing that made them really feel, ‘I’m contributing to society’. Or starting their first job. Driving, graduating from university.

“There are multiple little signifiers of what it means to contribute to society and they come up at different times and different circumstances.”

Carey Oppenheim, an expert in social policy relating to childhood and inequality, agreed that the pathways to becoming an adult have become “more complex, longer and more precarious – and they remain very unequal”. It left public policy and services increasingly out of step with how society has changed for young people, she said.

Oppenheim recently led a research project for the Nuffield Foundation designed to ask young people what it means to be a grownup in the context of a rapidly changing society. While the traditional markers of adulthood – getting a job, leaving home, settling into a relationship – are delayed for most, the support available to young people, such as specialist mental health services, suddenly stop at a certain, arbitrary point.

“The cliff edge at the age of 18, or wherever that cliff edge is, is not a very good way to organise support for young people as they navigate their transitions into adulthood,” said Oppenheim. As a result, her report recommended that early adulthood should be recognised as a distinct and extended phase of life, rather than something that does not exist one day and is suddenly attained the next.

“In terms of [the debate about] young people’s lives and how they achieve some of the markers of what adulthood is about, this feels like a really important time,” she said.

  • consent
  • scrutiny
  • youth
  • end
  • adulthood
  • age
  • armstrong
  • gentleman

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Campaigners back call for scrutiny of consent laws by Joanne Young
politics

Campaigners back call for scrutiny of consent laws by Joanne Young

Experts say no law states third-party consent is a valid defence and call for public debate and further education Campaigners have welcomed a call for scrutiny of consent laws by a survivor of drug-facilitated rape but said action must also focus on wider issues around sexual assault. Joanne Young, who was drugged and raped by her husband and sexually abused by men he invited into their home, warned of “serious questions about how the law deals with consent”.

Read →
‘I was drinking at 15, going to parties, being groomed and abused’: the grim reality of age-gap relationships
lifestyle

‘I was drinking at 15, going to parties, being groomed and abused’: the grim reality of age-gap relationships

Sometimes called Romeo and Juliet laws, rules already exist in some US states, Canada and France to prevent “age-gap relationships” or, to put it another way, the sexual exploitation of teenagers by adults. The suggestion from UK campaigners Close the Consent Gap is for it to be illegal to have an age gap of more than three years if anyone is under 18, and last week, Claire Waxman, the victims’ commissioner for England and Wales, called for “serious conversations” on the potential for legislative change.

Read →
GRNMA Ashanti warns against brain drain, holds youth boot camp to improve livelihoods of nurses
health

GRNMA Ashanti warns against brain drain, holds youth boot camp to improve livelihoods of nurses

Ashanti Regional Chairman of the Ghana Registered Nurses and Midwives Association (GRNMA), Jones Afriyie-Anto, has raised concerns over the significant brain drain associated with the Ghana Labour Exchange Programme (GLEP). Speaking on the sidelines of the maiden edition of the GRNMA Youth Boot Camp at Ejisu-Krapa, Afriyie-Anto lamented that an initiative meant for jobless nurses and midwives is instead targeting experienced specialists who constitute the backbone of Ghana’s health system for foreign employment.

Read →
Burnham seals trade and youth mobility deals in biggest step towards EU since Brexit
education

Burnham seals trade and youth mobility deals in biggest step towards EU since Brexit

Agreements reached on food and drink, emissions and to allow young people to move around continent, but may be derailed over student fees Andy Burnham has taken the biggest step towards deeper ties with the EU since Brexit, sealing deals to ease trade and create a mobility scheme for young people as he declared a “new world” of cooperation between the two sides. At a major summit in Brussels on Friday the EU and UK announced three deals, on food and drink, emissions trading and a youth mobility scheme, which will allow 100,000 young Britons to live, work, study and travel in the EU, with recip

Read →