politics

Victorian Labor MPs conduct a 'pre-mortem' in political death spiral

Victorian Labor MPs conduct a 'pre-mortem' in political death spiral

After three successive election victories, Victoria's Labor Party is coming to grips with what electoral failure looks like and is working out who is to blame.

They say history is written by the victors, but a deflated Labor Party, a week out from election day, is already in the throes of trying to write its own version.

Ben Carroll is in an unenviable position.

The party's popularity after nearly 12 years in office has collapsed; Carroll has inherited a budget weighed down by soaring debt and a high crime rate, which is only slowly turning around.

And he must go out every day to fight an election where voters have already thumbed their nose at Labor.

With public and private polling showing Labor will lose the election, Labor MPs, past and present, are already beginning to conduct a post-(pre)-mortem.

Some of the questions posed include: Was it the right decision to knife Jacinta Allan? Was it a good idea to call a royal commission? Is the campaign hitting the right issues? Why isn't Labor campaigning on its achievements since 2014?

Rather than focusing on the last week of campaigning, this is what is occupying Labor folk, which tells you everything you need to know about how they see their chances on November 28.

Much of the briefing and venting is about trying to secure or sabotage the legacy of the three Labor premiers: Ben Carroll, Jacinta Allan and Daniel Andrews.

"It is evident that the leadership change was a disaster, and that the premier and deputy are not up to the job,'' a former minister said.

"The change has damaged our government's brand at the worst possible time — four months out from the election."

A common criticism is that the new regime had no plan beyond changing leader, and that too much of the policy agenda has been to agree with the Coalition's rhetoric rather than highlighting the achievements of the 12 years.

Insiders say there was a months-long strategy leading up to the election, which was quickly lost.

"People [voters] aren't fools. They can know and agree that we did many great things over 12 years, and still be critical of some aspects of our government,'' the former minister said.

"For some voters, it's enough to keep them voting for Labor because you've stood by what you've delivered, and what you'll deliver in the future. But if you don't campaign on it, you throw away your greatest strength of incumbency."

Despite retreating from public life, Daniel Andrews remains a giant figure in Labor, and his spectre hangs over the campaign.

He led the government for nine of the past 12 years. It was Labor's most successful period.

He won three elections, increasing his majority in each one.

"There is a reason the Liberal's campaign is all about tying Ben to Jacinta and Daniel: voters f****** hate them,'' a senior ally of Carroll said.

Andrews instigated the Big Build and oversaw the massive spending that has contributed to Victoria's $173 billion net debt — a chunk of this due to COVID spending.

But he also was the lockdown premier, and some of the lingering frustration about this is washing through the electorate.

Those loyal to Andrews are placing the likely defeat at the feet of Carroll and those who led the coup; they ask what the plan was once Jacinta Allan was defeated.

Those in Carroll's camp bristle at this.

Those on team Carroll are infuriated that Labor internal critics do not even have the "decency" to wait until the campaign is over before "white-anting the movement into thinking it was unicorns and roses when she was in charge."

"In a few months' time, Jacinta Allan and her advisors will be in the box answering questions about what they knew and when. If I were these anonymous sources, I don't think I would be tying my mast to JA," a source said.

The issue that sealed Allan's fate was her steadfast resistance to calling any type of inquiry into the construction corruption allegations — an issue that would have overshadowed any attempt to press on with Labor's agenda.

We will never know if Labor would have done better under Jacinta Allan at this election, but under Ben Carroll, Labor's position has gotten worse.

The party is losing votes to the Liberals, One Nation and the Greens.

The Coalition is set to win government, with a historically low primary vote under 40.

A gripe for those Carroll critics is that the political message Labor has trotted out about a possible minority Liberal-One Nation government has, in fact, pushed voters wanting a change of government straight into the hands of the Liberals.

"The best campaign in history could not escape the baggage of this government," a Carroll backer says.

The Labor campaign machine, so fearsome for years, has never really got going.

All of this blood-letting is taking focus off the Coalition, who still have big questions to answer about costings and how it proposes to keep the lights, amid dire warnings in energy plans will worsen already shaky power security.

Jess Wilson is still yet to release the Coalition's costings. Economists keep asking how the Coalition is going to meet its targets.

Wilson says the costings are coming, but millions of Victorians will have voted before that happens.

On Friday, Carroll stood alongside his political mentor Steve Bracks, a man who also won three elections for Labor.

He had no problem complimenting Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan, will conceding their governments made mistakes — he said all governments do.

Bracks scored an upset win in 1999; a week out from election day, no one gave him a chance of knocking off the dominant Jeff Kennett.

But he did, and he said Ben Carroll could repeat history.

However, the fact Labor is now caught in venting and reprisals, rather than their opponents, shows that might be very wishful thinking.

  • labor
  • mps
  • death
  • spiral
  • election
  • victory
  • victoria
  • party

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

LP condemns rising political violence ahead of 2027 polls
politics

LP condemns rising political violence ahead of 2027 polls

By John Alechenu, Abuja The Labour Party (LP) has condemned the rising cases of politically motivated violence across the country ahead of the 2027 general elections, warning that the trend poses a threat to democracy and national stability. The National Publicity Secretary of the party, Ken Asogwa, stated this in an interview with Vanguard in Abuja, where he appealed to political parties and their supporters to exercise restraint in their conduct and utterances.

Read →
2027: Peter Obi is only hope Nigeria has this time – Cleopas
politics

2027: Peter Obi is only hope Nigeria has this time – Cleopas

Peter Obi is only hope Nigeria has this time – Cleopas. By Henry Umoru ABUJA- AHEAD of 2027 general elections, the national leadership of the Nigeria Democratic Congress, NDC has said its Presidential Candidate, Peter Obi is the only hope Nigeria has at this time.

Read →
Kindiki Warns Politicians Against Divisive Rhetoric Ahead of 2027 General Election
politics

Kindiki Warns Politicians Against Divisive Rhetoric Ahead of 2027 General Election

NAIROBI, Kenya Nov 21 – Deputy President Kithure Kindiki has urged politicians to avoid divisive rhetoric and incitement to violence ahead of the 2027 General Election, warning that ethnic mobilisation could undermine national unity and trigger conflict. Accompanied by Nakuru Governor Susan Kihika, Nakuru Town East MP David Gikaria and Nakuru Woman Representative Lisa Chelule, Kindiki said political competition should not translate into enmity, adding that the best candidates should win through a democratic process.

Read →