science

Amid divisions, COP31 president says climate talks near deal

Amid divisions, COP31 president says climate talks near deal

The push for an explicit commitment to transition away from fossil fuels remained one of the biggest obstacles to consensus at the conference

COP31 President and Türkiye’s Minister of Environment, Murat Kurum

Abdulkareem Mojeed, Fortune Eromonsele and Uchenna Igwe

The ongoing Climate negotiations in Antalya, Türkiye, are nearing a final agreement after talks spilled beyond the initially scheduled conclusion period of 20 November. Negotiators spent the weekend struggling to bridge divisions over fossil fuel phase-out, climate finance and other contentious issues.

The COP31 co-presidents, Australia’s Chris Bowen and Türkiye’s Murat Kurum, held consultations with delegations from nearly 200 countries late into Saturday, with countries and campaigners increasingly frustrated by the lack of progress.

The talks stalled amid disagreements over demands by a coalition of countries to include a clear commitment to transitioning away from fossil fuels in the final outcome, as well as calls by developing nations for stronger guarantees on climate finance to help them adapt to worsening climate impacts.

Many frustrated participants and delegates have since vacated the venue. PREMIUM TIMES observed on Saturday that the venue, which was filled by nearly 100,000 participants, was almost empty, as parties failed to reach consensus on critical issues.

However, the conference appeared to move closer to a deal on Sunday after the presidency released a revised draft outcome, which it hopes will secure consensus among parties.

“We believe that we have put forward a text which all the parties can agree upon,” Mr Kurum told a late-night plenary session, adding that the conference would reconvene on Sunday morning to consider and approve the agreement.

The latest draft followed intensive consultations between Australia, which is leading the negotiations, Türkiye, the host country, and delegations representing countries across the economic and political spectrum.

The COP31 presidency published its third draft at about 3 a.m. on Sunday, several hours after the release was initially expected on Friday.

PREMIUM TIMES observed that the latest draft is a 94-paragraph, 10-page document, which is expected to form the basis of the final agreement. It is basically a revision of the previous drafts, which were criticised for lacking ambition, particularly over fossil fuel transition and climate finance.

Although Mr Kurum described the text as a final version, further changes could still be made during the closing plenary.

The latest draft, however, has raised concerns among campaigners and some negotiating parties over the absence of explicit commitments on fossil fuel transition, adaptation finance and timelines for the next Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) assessment reports.

On adaptation finance, the draft does not include the $120 billion target demanded by developing countries. Instead, it proposes discussions on an implementation pathway towards tripling adaptation finance under the climate finance work programme.

It also encourages countries to voluntarily provide or continue providing climate finance while calling for further efforts to mobilise resources for the loss and damage fund.

On fossil fuels, the draft makes no direct reference to transitioning away from them but recalls the outcome of COP28 in the United Arab Emirates, which called for a “just, orderly and equitable” transition away from fossil fuels.

It also omits reference to the Brazil-led global roadmap for transitioning away from fossil fuels, a key demand of several countries and campaign groups.

The draft retains the “35 by 35” electrification target promoted by the COP31 presidency, which seeks to increase the share of electricity in global energy consumption to 35 per cent by 2035. However, the goal is included among a range of options for global cooperation rather than as a firm commitment.

It also retains provisions on limiting the magnitude and duration of global temperature overshoot beyond 1.5 degrees Celsius, while proposing a high-level dialogue at COP32 on the science of overshoot.

On carbon capture, utilisation and storage, the draft drops numerical targets but retains a call to accelerate the technology towards an aspirational global scale of one gigatonne by 2035.

Other provisions include a two-year work programme on mountains and climate change, discussions on reforming the COP process, and references to the cross-border impacts of trade measures, particularly on developing countries.

The push for an explicit commitment to transition away from fossil fuels remains one of the biggest obstacles to a consensus at the conference.

A coalition of about 130 countries has insisted that the final outcome must include language on phasing out fossil fuels, arguing that they remain the primary drivers of global warming.

Maina Talia, climate minister of Tuvalu, a low-lying Pacific island nation highly vulnerable to rising sea levels, said the issue was a red line for his country.

“This [inclusion of a reference to fossil fuels] is a red line for us. We’re talking about the root cause of all this. [Without it] we are wasting our time here,” he said.

Mohamed Adow, director of the Power Shift Africa think tank, said countries came to Antalya expecting progress on public climate finance, adaptation and fossil fuels, but were instead struggling to prevent governments from retreating from previous commitments.

“We came to Antalya needing progress on public climate finance, adaptation and fossil fuels. Instead, we are fighting to stop governments retreating from promises they have already made. Rich countries have spent two weeks finding reasons not to deliver the [financial] support they promised. It feels like this meeting is unravelling,” he said.

The disagreement over fossil fuels also intersected with debates over carbon capture and storage (CCS), a technology strongly supported by Saudi Arabia and other fossil fuel-dependent countries.

While some nations argue that CCS could help reduce emissions, others fear it could prolong reliance on oil, gas and coal by allowing continued production under the guise of emissions reduction.

Negotiators have explored possible compromises, including weakening references to CCS while strengthening commitments to electrification.

Campaigners blamed fossil fuel interests and wealthy countries’ failure to deliver promised climate finance for the prolonged negotiations.

Nick Dearden, director of Global Justice Now, said the influence of fossil fuel interests continued to undermine efforts to reach meaningful climate agreements.

“This must be the last time we allow fossil fuel interests, which are profiting so handsomely from the climate crisis, to hold us to ransom,” he said.

He added that efforts to combat climate change would remain constrained as long as powerful economic interests continued to profit from fossil fuels.

The demand for a fossil fuel transition roadmap had featured in an earlier draft of the COP31 outcome but was removed from a subsequent version published on Thursday.

Following unsuccessful negotiations, the European Union, the United Kingdom, least developed countries, small island states and several African countries joined a march to the presidency’s office on Saturday evening, demanding that the commitment be reinstated.

The prolonged negotiations have also raised questions about the effectiveness of the COP31 presidency, which is jointly led by Australia and Türkiye following a compromise reached last year after both countries sought to host the conference.

Claudio Angelo of Observatorio do Clima criticised the arrangement, arguing that the dual presidency had weakened the process.

“It goes to show how a weak presidency, split between two countries with little tradition in climate diplomacy, can be detrimental to a process already victimised by geopolitics,” he said.

The negotiations are taking place against the backdrop of growing warnings that global warming is likely to exceed the 1.5-degree Celsius threshold agreed under the Paris Agreement, increasing the risks of extreme weather and other climate impacts.

Delegates were expected to reconvene on Sunday morning to consider the latest draft, with the presidency seeking to secure consensus and bring the prolonged talks to a close.

At COP28 in Dubai (December 2023), the then COP President, Sultan Al Jaber, broke a major negotiation deadlock by transitioning deadlocked formal talks into an open, circle-style Emirati “Majlis”, which ultimately paved the way for the historic UAE Consensus. Murat Kurum of Turkey and Chris Bowen of Australia, who are leading the talks in Antalya, are being pressured to make this year’s summit a success, as many observers are already describing the COP as a “failed COP”.

  • president
  • climate
  • deal
  • division
  • talk
  • push
  • commitment
  • transition

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Cop31 talks go into overtime as fossil fuels vanish from draft deal
science

Cop31 talks go into overtime as fossil fuels vanish from draft deal

African ministers say they ‘didn’t come here to beg’, with civil society groups calling it the ‘worst Cop ever’ Crucial climate talks headed into overtime on the last official day of the Cop31 UN summit as countries continued to argue over a draft deal that was silent on fossil fuels, with a host of other contentious issues complicating negotiations. Nearly 200 countries struggled to bridge their differences after two weeks of intense talks and impassioned speeches in Antalya, Turkey, about the effects of climate breakdown around the world, with a scheduled finish of Friday evening breached.

Read →
Countries race to secure COP31 deal after fossil fuel row
science

Countries race to secure COP31 deal after fossil fuel row

The COP31 climate talks spilled into Saturday as countries raced to secure a deal after a draft text dropped all mention of fossil fuels, exposing deep divisions over how to tackle global warming. “We are close to the finish line, but we are not there yet,” COP31 President Murat Kurum, who is Turkey’s environment minister, told an assembly late Friday that approved some technical matters.

Read →
Climate talks stall as countries mull showdown with Saudi Arabia over fossil fuel phaseout
science

Climate talks stall as countries mull showdown with Saudi Arabia over fossil fuel phaseout

Cop31 summit ‘unravelling’ as governments fail to agree on transition to renewables and aid for developing countries Climate talks reached a standstill on Saturday night in Turkey as some countries mulled whether to force a showdown with Saudi Arabia and its allies over the global need to phase out fossil fuels. The joint presidencies of the Cop31 UN climate summit, Australia and Turkey, held meetings with scores of countries throughout Saturday, until late evening, as the fortnight-long talks overran without resolution, with countries and campaigners growing increasingly frustrated at the lac

Read →