crime

Media groups challenge India’s privacy law at top court

Media groups challenge India’s privacy law at top court

News organisations are challenging the law, arguing it could hamper investigative journalism and endanger sources.

The Indian government’s privacy law, which would require journalists to seek consent from people they write about, amounts to pre-censorship and could lead to newsrooms shutting down, media groups have told the Supreme Court.

A group of 21 news publishers, including companies owned by billionaires Mukesh Ambani and Gautam Adani, challenged Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s law on Tuesday, arguing it would trample upon investigative work and allow the government to identify journalists’ sources, according to The Indian Express newspaper.

“It is changing the whole concept of what is news,” Madhavi Goradia Divan, the lawyer for the Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA), told judges.

“Newsrooms will shut down, if we have to ask for permission … it’s then a complete regime of pre-censorship.”

The Supreme Court said it would hear the case next month.

Media companies received assurances in an August meeting with the government that the law would protect press freedom, but not having a written exemption for journalists as in the European Union, Singapore and Britain was alarming, the news publishers said in a filing earlier this month.

The DNPA’s members include Ambani’s Network18, which has seven digital news platforms, Adani’s NDTV and other high-profile media groups including the Indian Express and Times Internet, which is part of the Times of India group, publisher of India’s largest-selling English-language daily.

A key concern in the law is the requirement of consent, says the group’s filing, cited by the Reuters news agency.

A social media platform or online retailer can seek consent from users when they sign up, but the DNPA has argued that requiring a journalist to notify the subject of an investigation and seek consent “would allow that subject to destroy evidence, intimidate witnesses”.

The law also lets people withdraw consent at any time and demand that their data be erased, without any public-interest safeguard, which the DNPA says could force its members to unpublish or heavily redact a factual news report.

News publishers are concerned that a federal authority created under the law can impose fines for noncompliance, and grants powers to New Delhi to block access to any information in the “interests of the general public”, which would curtail press freedom, the DNPA said.

From next year, the law will also let New Delhi order any organisation handling personal data “to furnish such information as it may call for”, putting newsrooms at risk of having to divulge sources, the filing said.

It can also deter whistleblowers from sharing information on corruption, corporate wrongdoing or electoral malpractice with reporters, the DNPA argued.

The “nakedly unguided” provision must be quashed, the DNPA said, adding that the power “can extend to privileged communications in possession of a reporter or the informant.”

  • law
  • media
  • india
  • privacy
  • court
  • group
  • news
  • organisation

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

crime

Toluwanisings: Defendant fails to meet bail conditions, spends weekend in correctional centre

Joshua Oladipupo, a defendant, facing trial over alleged posting of fake news on the death of gospel singer, Bayonile Olayemi, popularly called Toluwanisings, failed to perfect his bail and spent the weekend at Agodi Correctional Centre, Ibadan. Investigation by the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) on Monday revealed that Oladipupo, arraigned at the Iyaganku Magistrates’ Court in Ibadan on Friday, was yet to meet his bail conditions.

Read →
Court hears NT teen planned a 'massacre' at several locations
crime

Court hears NT teen planned a 'massacre' at several locations

A teenage boy charged with terrorism-related offences allegedly wrote “that a massacre needs to happen”, naming potential locations including a church, a Northern Territory court has heard. The 14-year-old also allegedly had an Al-Qaeda training manual on his computer.

Read →
World’s top court to rule if Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya
crime

World’s top court to rule if Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya

International court of justice has never before found a state guilty of genocide, and ruling will have implications for case against Israel The world’s top court will deliver a judgment this week on whether Myanmar committed genocide against its Rohingya minority, in a landmark case that will set a critical 21st-century benchmark for the gravest of all international crimes. The closely watched judgment could become one of the most significant moments in international law since the end of the second world war.

Read →
Defamation Charges: DSS Asks Appeal Court To Uphold ₦100m Fine Against SERAP
crime

Defamation Charges: DSS Asks Appeal Court To Uphold ₦100m Fine Against SERAP

The Department of State Services (DSS) is asking the Court of Appeal in Abuja to uphold the ₦100m fine imposed on the Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) for defaming two of its operatives through false publications. A High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), in a judgment delivered on May 5, awarded damages against SERAP and Mr. Oluwadare, who were sued as the first and second defendants.

Read →