business

Unpaid carers say chancellor’s plan to scrap allowance cliff edge falls short

Unpaid carers say chancellor’s plan to scrap allowance cliff edge falls short

Digital taper system for benefit expected in budget, but those already hit with overpayments will still have to pay “On the surface it sounds really positive – and I really hope that it is,” says unpaid carer Guy Shahar of the government’s decision to abolish the notorious carer’s allowance cliff edge. And he notes that the cliff edge remains in place for four more years, potentially catching out more carers.

Digital taper system for benefit expected in budget, but those already hit with overpayments will still have to pay

“On the surface it sounds really positive – and I really hope that it is,” says unpaid carer Guy Shahar of the government’s decision to abolish the notorious carer’s allowance cliff edge.

But Shahar is angry that most carers hit with unjust overpayments in the past will still have to repay them, for all the promise of a different future. And he notes that the cliff edge remains in place for four more years, potentially catching out more carers.

“They are effectively saying: ‘We know that the system was unfair but we will still punish you for having been the victim of an unfair system,’” he says.

The chancellor is expected to announce the introduction of a new digital taper system into the carer’s allowance benefit in the budget, in effect ending a rule that has landed hundreds of thousands of carers with life-shattering financial penalties.

Unpaid carers have broadly welcomed the move – and there is a general acknowledgment that ministers are moving positively, if slowly, to reform a system with inbuilt injustices and terrible management that birthed what became known as the carer’s allowance scandal.

But there is also disbelief that the new system – which must be built from scratch – will be live before 2030, and a feeling that the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has a lot more to do to regain the trust of unpaid carers.

Shahar and his wife, Oksana, who care for their autistic son, Daniel, were victims of the cliff edge. This rule meant that a carer who earns more than the weekly earnings limit allowed – currently £204 – will forfeit their entire week’s carer’s allowance payment, now £86.45.

A carer who earned a penny over the limit for a year would breach it by 52p but would be asked to repay £4,495.40. Last year, the Shahars were landed with a £10,000 repayment bill for relatively trivial earnings breaches dating back five years.

Oksana had earned more than the allowed limit by just £1.92 a week on average while juggling caring with part-time minimum wage jobs. In some weeks, she was paid just 38p more than the carer’s allowance earnings threshold.

Over the period, she earned a total of £505 more than the rules allowed – but was duly issued with a bill for £10,130.45 – plus a £50 civil penalty. The Shahars are challenging the charge at tribunal but the stress is real and ongoing.

Unpaid carer Elizabeth Tait, who looks after her disabled son, Oliver, is staggered that the taper system is years away: “We live in the age of tech; it is ludicrous it is going to take so long. They need to make it a priority.”

Tait, a former teacher and now a private tutor and educational consultant who ended up with a bill for £1,623 after unwittingly breaching the earnings threshold, says the carer’s allowance cliff edge symbolises a “whole crazy system”.

Reforming carer’s allowance is essential but it needs to be part of a wider examination of the crucial role of unpaid care in propping up England’s social care arrangements, she says: “We care willingly and lovingly, and yet we end up a casualty of the system.”

Andrea Tucker, who for years acted as an unpaid carer for her mother, is one of a handful of carers to challenge a cliff edge penalty and win, successfully overturning a £4,600 overpayment at a tribunal in February 2025.

As a result, she did not have to repay the money, although she suffered months of stress along the way. She welcomes the decision to introduce a taper but believes carers punished unfairly by draconian rules should be compensated.

“People repaying overpayments should no longer have to, and they should be given back what they have already paid,” she says.

Tucker recalls how for years she carefully monitored her monthly earnings from her part-time charity shop role to stay under the limit. Some weeks she would work six hours for nothing so as not to risk losing carer’s allowance.

Even so, she was hit with an overpayment when DWP officials decided – unlawfully – that she could not average her earnings over a one-year period.

There is raw bitterness among carers about the cliff edge, she says. “My friend is paying back their overpayment at £10 a month. She went £12.50 over as a result of receiving holiday pay. She always tells me: ‘I hope I die before I have paid it all back.’”

  • cliff
  • edge
  • carer
  • allowance
  • unpaid
  • chancellor
  • plan
  • overpayment

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Digital-only banks could be forced to fund high street banking
business

Digital-only banks could be forced to fund high street banking

Treasury-backed review says customers of banks such as Monzo and Revolut often rely on physical cash services Digital banks like Monzo and Revolut could be forced to pay towards high street banking facilities, after a government-backed review outlined plans to protect face-to-face financial services across the UK. The access to banking review, which was released on Monday, was commissioned by the Treasury earlier this year, and addresses the dwindling options for nearly 3 million people who regularly rely on in-person banking across the UK.

Read →
The future of banking in Ghana: Why execution matters in the digital age
business

The future of banking in Ghana: Why execution matters in the digital age

Banking in Ghana is changing as more customers use digital channels to make payments, transfer funds, manage accounts and conduct business. Digital Banking at the Centre of Customer Experience Customers increasingly expect to transfer funds, make payments and manage their accounts without visiting a branch.

Read →
European football body’s secret plan to go global leaves Fifa on tenterhooks
sports

European football body’s secret plan to go global leaves Fifa on tenterhooks

In September the increasingly powerful European Football Clubs body announced a “feasibility study” into exactly how it can become established on a more global scale, morphing into an organisation that represents clubs all over the world. It has the potential to transform a landscape destabilised by the scandals surrounding Fifa and Gianni Infantino.

Read →
Housing allowance glitch threatens my partner’s leave to remain
general

Housing allowance glitch threatens my partner’s leave to remain

DWP admits it is making a mistake that affects his immigration status but says it can’t put it right The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) is knowingly paying me too much local housing allowance because of a system glitch and it could have serious implications for my partner’s immigration status. However, the DWP is paying me the higher one-bedroom rate for couples.

Read →
Failed UK asylum seekers to lose five-day grace period and face immediate removal
lifestyle

Failed UK asylum seekers to lose five-day grace period and face immediate removal

Home Office plans condemned as ‘distressing’ by refugee charities Asylum seekers who have exhausted the formal appeals process will be stripped of a five-day grace period and become eligible for immediate removal under Home Office plans condemned as “distressing” by refugee charities. Shabana Mahmood, the home secretary, will amend a bill currently before parliament to allow Immigration Enforcement officers to detain and remove people who have unsuccessfully appealed against their asylum or immigration claim being rejected without further notice.

Read →