crime

Ensuring prisoners can’t refuse to attend court

Ensuring prisoners can’t refuse to attend court

One prison officer says existing rules on offenders making court appearances should be enforced rather than introducing fresh sanctions The report on judges being given powers to punish prisoners who refuse to attend court raises a question about why we appear to have abandoned a straightforward approach that once worked (Criminals who refuse to attend sentencing face losing prison privileges under new rules, 22 October). When I joined the Prison Service as an officer more than 30 years ago, prisoners were not permitted to decide whether they would attend court.

One prison officer says existing rules on offenders making court appearances should be enforced rather than introducing fresh sanctions

The report on judges being given powers to punish prisoners who refuse to attend court raises a question about why we appear to have abandoned a straightforward approach that once worked (Criminals who refuse to attend sentencing face losing prison privileges under new rules, 22 October).

When I joined the Prison Service as an officer more than 30 years ago, prisoners were not permitted to decide whether they would attend court. If they refused to go voluntarily, they could be escorted under restraint where necessary.

The result was predictable: few prisoners refused, because they knew their refusal would not prevent them from appearing.

There is a wider lesson here for the administration of justice. When noncompliance becomes a means of delaying or obstructing the system, introducing additional punishments may be less effective than ensuring that lawful instructions are carried out in the first place. Prisoners have rights, and the use of restraint must always be lawful, proportionate and justified. But those rights do not extend to exercising a veto over the judicial process.

After more than three decades, I find it difficult to understand why a principle that was once routine now appears to require a fresh solution. Sometimes, effective public administration is not about creating new sanctions but about having the resolve and resources to enforce existing rules. Name and address supplied

  • court
  • prisoner
  • prison
  • officer
  • rule
  • offender
  • appearance
  • sanction

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

‘Master manipulator’ police officer should not be released early from UK prison, says ex-partner
crime

‘Master manipulator’ police officer should not be released early from UK prison, says ex-partner

Catherine Dobson calls for exception to England and Wales early release scheme for police who abuse position of trust ‘He’s a master manipulator’: one woman’s fight against her abuser’s early release | Podcast Michael Harvey worked as a detective in Lancashire police’s sexual offenders management unit when he met Catherine Dobson, using the police database to track her movements after a chance encounter in a supermarket.

Read →
Fears grow over US sanctions on ICJ judges ahead of Myanmar genocide ruling
world

Fears grow over US sanctions on ICJ judges ahead of Myanmar genocide ruling

A ruling against Myanmar could set precedent for court’s judgment on Israel’s actions in Gaza Fears are growing that the US could impose sanctions on judges at the international court of justice, including this year’s Nobel peace prize winner, Navi Pillay, if the court rules on Thursday that the Myanmar government committed genocide against the Rohingya. The ICJ has never found a state responsible for committing genocide, and a significant factor in previous cases has been how to prove “intent” in a crime defined as acts committed with the “intent to destroy, in whole or in part” a national, e

Read →