politicsUnder review

Supreme Court won’t settle a debate through constitutional interpretation – Kwaku Azar on NPP presidential term limit suit

Supreme Court won’t settle a debate through constitutional interpretation – Kwaku Azar on NPP presidential term limit suit

Legal scholar Kwaku Azar Asare has questioned whether the New Patriotic Party’s (NPP) suit at the Supreme Court seeking an interpretation of the presidential term limit presents a justiciable constitutional dispute or amounts to a request for an advisory opinion. Mr Asare also referred to Ex parte Akosah, a case associated with the principles governing when questions of constitutional interpretation arise and should be referred to the Supreme Court.

Legal scholar Kwaku Azar Asare has questioned whether the New Patriotic Party’s (NPP) suit at the Supreme Court seeking an interpretation of the presidential term limit presents a justiciable constitutional dispute or amounts to a request for an advisory opinion.

The NPP has filed a suit at the Supreme Court seeking an interpretation of Article 66(2) of the 1992 Constitution, which provides for a presidential term of four years and limits a person to two terms in office.

The party is seeking a declaration that the two-term limit applies whether the terms are consecutive or non-consecutive.

The action has drawn attention to the constitutional implications of presidential term limits ahead of the 2028 general election. However, the filing of the suit does not, in itself, establish that President John Dramani Mahama intends to seek another term.

In a Facebook post, Mr Asare argued that the party’s action appeared to differ from previous constitutional cases it pursued, including the 31st December Case and a challenge to police permit requirements for public demonstrations.

He said those cases involved identifiable government actions or existing laws alleged to be inconsistent with the Constitution, rather than disagreements over constitutional interpretation in the abstract.

“Notice something important about these cases. The NPP of yore challenged identifiable governmental actions and existing laws that allegedly violated the Constitution. The Court was not being invited merely to settle an interesting public debate,” he wrote.

Mr Asare argued that the current writ had not identified an allegedly unconstitutional enactment, act or omission requiring judicial intervention.

“What enactment is being challenged? What unconstitutional act or omission is alleged? Nobody has filed to contest a third presidential election. No electoral authority has determined that a person who has already been elected President twice is eligible for a third election,” he stated.

“At best, on the facts reported, there is a public debate over what the Constitution permits.”

He maintained that disagreement over the meaning of a constitutional provision does not, by itself, establish a justiciable controversy.

To support his argument, Mr Asare cited Bilson v Attorney-General [1993-94] 1 GLR 104, a Supreme Court decision concerning the limits of its jurisdiction to interpret constitutional provisions in the absence of an actual dispute.

“The Court held that it had jurisdiction to interpret constitutional provisions in the context of disputes, but no jurisdiction to tender advice to prospective litigants,” he wrote.

Mr Asare said the case illustrated the distinction between resolving a genuine constitutional dispute and providing judicial guidance on a hypothetical question.

He argued that the distinction was important in determining whether the NPP’s action met the threshold for judicial consideration.

Mr Asare also referred to Ex parte Akosah, a case associated with the principles governing when questions of constitutional interpretation arise and should be referred to the Supreme Court.

He cautioned against relying on the decision to suggest that every disagreement over constitutional meaning automatically warrants the Court’s intervention.

“But an important qualification is often overlooked. Ex parte Akosah arose in the context of determining when a lower court should refer a constitutional interpretation question to the Supreme Court. It was not an invitation to citizens to manufacture competing interpretations and demand that the Supreme Court resolve them,” he argued.

He added that competing views expressed by lawyers, academics and political commentators did not automatically create a justiciable constitutional controversy.

“Citizens, lawyers, academics, and political parties are free to express different views about the meaning of constitutional provisions. That is healthy constitutional discourse. But merely because someone advances a different interpretation does not mean the Supreme Court must be invited to settle the disagreement,” he wrote.

Mr Asare urged the Supreme Court to exercise restraint in determining which constitutional questions require judicial intervention.

“The Supreme Court is a court of law, not a constitutional advice centre. And the Court itself must remain disciplined, resisting the temptation to wade into every constitutional controversy merely because the question is politically important, intellectually interesting, or generating considerable public attention,” he stated.

He argued that scarce judicial resources should be directed towards resolving genuine disputes rather than providing what he described as constitutional consultations.

Mr Asare suggested that if the writ failed to disclose a justiciable cause of action, the Court should dismiss it at the earliest procedurally appropriate stage.

He proposed a brief ruling dismissing the action for want of jurisdiction, without prejudice to a properly constituted case arising from a justiciable controversy.

  • court
  • term
  • supreme
  • interpretation
  • npp
  • limit
  • suit
  • debate

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Courts must stop installing candidates rejected at polls -Justice Adefope-Okojie
politics

Courts must stop installing candidates rejected at polls -Justice Adefope-Okojie

By Innocent Anaba Justice Oludotun Adefope-Okojie, has warned Nigerian courts against installing candidates voters rejected through judicial rulings. Speaking on “Electoral Process in Nigeria: Managing the Boundaries of Judicial Intervention,” at the 2026 GAVEL International Annual Lecture, in Lagos, Justice Adefope-Okojie said: “The credibility of an electoral system depends not only on the conduct of elections but also on the existence of effective mechanisms for resolving disputes arising before, during, and after elections.

Read →
UGEL to seek court interpretation of Rent Act’s applicability to university hostels
education

UGEL to seek court interpretation of Rent Act’s applicability to university hostels

The University of Ghana Enterprise Limited (UGEL) is preparing to take the Rent Control Commission to court to seek a judicial interpretation of the Rent Act and establish whether university-managed hostels fall within the scope of the legislation Chief Executive Officer of UGEL, Yawo Agbesi, said the move is intended to clarify whether the law applies to student accommodation facilities operated by universities. The development follows a confrontation between Acting Rent Commissioner Frederick Opoku and a hostel manager during an inspection of UGEL facilities on the University of Ghana…

Read →
Kwakye Ofosu challenges NPP’s principle on presidential jet purchase, cites 2000 parliamentary debate
politics

Kwakye Ofosu challenges NPP’s principle on presidential jet purchase, cites 2000 parliamentary debate

Speaking on JoyNews’ The Pulse on Tuesday, November 17, Mr Kwakye Ofosu challenged the Ranking Member on Parliament’s Foreign Affairs Committee, Samuel Abu Jinapor, to explain what he described as the NPP’s inconsistent position on the matter. Reading from the February 15, 2000 edition of the Parliamentary Hansard, Mr Kwakye Ofosu quoted Nana Akufo-Addo as saying that at a time when the country needed greater public investment in health and tertiary education, the government was considering spending $19 million over five years on an aircraft for the President.

Read →
Government claims to be retooling Air Force, but bought a presidential jet – Abu Jinapor
politics

Government claims to be retooling Air Force, but bought a presidential jet – Abu Jinapor

Member of Parliament for Damongo, Samuel Abu Jinapor, has criticised the Mahama-led government’s justification for buying a new presidential aircraft, arguing that the purchase is for the President’s use rather than to retool the Ghana Air Force. Mr Jinapor said Mr Ablakwa had referenced Namibia’s 30-year-old presidential aircraft, the United States’ 31-year-old Air Force One and French President Emmanuel Macron’s aircraft, commissioned in 2010, the same year as Ghana’s Falcon jet.

Read →