crime

Court dismisses Adu-Boahene’s bid to strike out portions of prosecution’s reply to his no-case submission

Court dismisses Adu-Boahene’s bid to strike out portions of prosecution’s reply to his no-case submission

The Accra High Court has refused a request by former National Signals Bureau Director-General Kwabena Adu-Boahene and his co-accused to expunge parts of the prosecution’s written arguments in the ongoing criminal trial. Deputy Attorney-General Dr Justice Srem-Sai opposed the application, contending that the court had no general jurisdiction to strike out parts of a lawyer’s written address merely because the opposing party challenged their accuracy.

The Accra High Court has refused a request by former National Signals Bureau Director-General Kwabena Adu-Boahene and his co-accused to expunge parts of the prosecution’s written arguments in the ongoing criminal trial. The defence had asked the court to remove sections of the prosecution’s response to the accused persons’ submission of no case to answer, alleging that some passages relied on statements witnesses had not made and evidence that was not established during the trial.

In dismissing the application, the court said it was not required to conduct a separate inquiry into the accuracy of lawyers’ written arguments or strike them out because one side disputed their account of the evidence. The judge emphasised that the court’s decision must be guided by testimony given in court and exhibits formally admitted into evidence, rather than claims made by either side in written submissions.

Defence counsel Samuel Atta Akyea, who filed the application, argued that portions of the prosecution’s submissions dated October 9, 2026, did not reflect the proceedings. He maintained that allowing the disputed passages to stand could mislead the court and undermine a fair determination of the case. He also argued that legal submissions should be based on evidence properly before the court and should not attribute statements to witnesses who had not made them.

Deputy Attorney-General Dr Justice Srem-Sai opposed the application, contending that the court had no general jurisdiction to strike out parts of a lawyer’s written address merely because the opposing party challenged their accuracy. He argued that the judge could examine the trial record and assess the prosecution’s arguments against the evidence without expunging any portion of the submissions.

He further maintained that written addresses assist the court but do not replace the evidence itself. The court agreed that written arguments do not constitute evidence and said any reliance on material that was not established at trial would carry no evidential weight in determining the case. It also noted that the defence had an opportunity to address the alleged inaccuracies in its reply to the prosecution’s submissions.

In the court’s view, counsel’s responsibility was to draw attention to any disputed representation and allow the judge to assess the actual record. The judge said the court would rely only on evidence properly presented and admitted during the trial, regardless of whether either party had accurately characterised that evidence in its written address.

On that basis, the court declined to examine the substantive merits of the defence application and dismissed it. The ruling concerns the disputed written submissions and does not, by itself, determine whether the accused persons have a case to answer.

  • court
  • submission
  • prosecution
  • evidence
  • case
  • trial
  • reply
  • argument

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Prosecution closes case against Wontumi; court sets December 17 deadline for defence
crime

Prosecution closes case against Wontumi; court sets December 17 deadline for defence

The Accra High Court has directed former Ashanti Regional New Patriotic Party (NPP) Chairman, Bernard Antwi-Boasiako, popularly known as Chairman Wontumi, to file a submission of no case to answer by December 17, 2026, following the closure of the prosecution’s case in the Tano Nimiri illegal mining trial. A key witness in the trial is Edward Akuoko, a former manager of Akonta Mining Company, who was initially charged alongside Mr Wontumi but was later discharged and called as the first prosecution witness.

Read →
Wontumi loses application seeking details of former manager’s deal with prosecution
technology

Wontumi loses application seeking details of former manager’s deal with prosecution

The Accra High Court has dismissed an application by lawyers for former Ashanti Regional New Patriotic Party (NPP) Chairman, Bernard Antwi-Boasiako, popularly known as Chairman Wontumi, seeking to compel the prosecution to disclose its agreement with the first prosecution witness in the ongoing Tano Nimiri illegal mining case. The application relates to Edward Akuoko, a former manager of Akonta Mining Company Limited, who was initially charged alongside Mr Wontumi but was later discharged and called as the prosecution’s first witness.

Read →
Wontumi’s lawyer to appeal High Court’s refusal to release prosecution deal with key witness
crime

Wontumi’s lawyer to appeal High Court’s refusal to release prosecution deal with key witness

Lawyer for former Ashanti Regional New Patriotic Party (NPP) Chairman Bernard Antwi-Boasiako, popularly known as Chairman Wontumi, Samuel Atta Akyea, says he is considering an appeal against a High Court ruling refusing to compel the prosecution to disclose its agreement with the first prosecution witness in the Tano Nimiri illegal mining case. The Accra High Court dismissed an application by Wontumi’s legal team seeking disclosure of the agreement between the prosecution and Edward Akuoko, Wontumi’s former manager, who has become the first prosecution witness in the case.

Read →
‘Fake Agency’ Case: Adeyemi in custody for his own safety, ICPC tells court
crime

‘Fake Agency’ Case: Adeyemi in custody for his own safety, ICPC tells court

… as defendants plead not guilty, beg for bail By Ikechukwu Nnochiri ABUJA — The Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission (ICPC) said on Wednesday that it kept the self-styled Director-General (DG) of the alleged “non-existent” Presidential Foreign Investment Promotion Council (PFIPC), Prince Adeniyi Adeyemi, in custody for his own safety. It therefore prayed the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), sitting at Maitama in Abuja, to reject an application that Adeyemi filed to be released on bail pending the determination of the criminal charge against…

Read →