business

This budget fails to live up to Andy Burnham’s grand rhetoric

This budget fails to live up to Andy Burnham’s grand rhetoric

Caitlin Boswell of Tax Justice UK and others on what Aditya Chakrabortty described as a ‘Martin Lewis budget’ Aditya Chakrabortty was spot-on in his analysis of John Healey’s budget (Burnham promised big change – where was it?

Caitlin Boswell of Tax Justice UK and others on what Aditya Chakrabortty described as a ‘Martin Lewis budget’

Aditya Chakrabortty was spot-on in his analysis of John Healey’s budget (Burnham promised big change – where was it? Instead we got the Martin Lewis budget, 28 October). It was a drop in the ocean of what is needed to bring about the scale of change this country needs and, importantly, was promised by Andy Burnham.

As the affordability crisis rages on, people may feel some relief at the small cost of living measures announced for households and businesses. But when we’ve been told we’ll get a wholesale reset and an end to neoliberalism, 4p off the price of gherkins and a temporary tiny bank tax isn’t going to cut it.

So, what’s the solution? The government must fairly tax the vast fortunes of the richest people and corporations, left mostly untouched. Recouping the massive wealth and profits siphoned off to shady tax havens each year, equalising how the tax system treats income from wealth and work, and building HMRC’s capacity to properly measure and collect tax from the very richest would raise tens of billions to help pay for targeted, meaningful cost of living support and Burnham’s ambitious plans to fix the housing crisis, fund social care and devolve power and wealth to every region.

Reforming capital gains tax – a proposal supported by members of his own party – would make things fairer and raise around £19.7bn a year, enough to build 90,000 new council homes (the number needed each year to end the housing crisis) and train 128,000 new NHS nurses.

This government cannot survive much longer on vibes alone, and Labour is already on its last chance. Burnham must use his 10-year plan and spending review to lay out a proper roadmap to genuinely improve lives and transform the country, otherwise he risks being remembered for gherkins, which isn’t much better than Liz Truss’s lettuce. Caitlin Boswell Deputy director, external affairs, Tax Justice UK

Aditya Chakrabortty is right to say that Andy Burnham’s grand rhetoric and romantic notions need to be translated into a bold programme of change. Unless this government tackles income and wealth inequality seriously, people’s anger will unceremoniously sweep it from office at the next election. Hugh Firth Newcastle upon Tyne

Living in a rented band B property, my “breathing space” was short-lived on budget day. The £100 energy payment announced by the chancellor will be entirely swallowed up by Northern Energy’s own announcement via email at 5pm the same day: “a temporary fuel surcharge of £17 per delivery will be applied to LPG deliveries as from your next delivery”.

Although this is “temporary”, customers are warned that the need to cover the elevated fuel costs is likely to remain for the foreseeable future. I had six deliveries of LPG last year – do the maths. Juliet Lunn Cockermouth, Cumbria

Once again, tax thresholds are frozen. What a missed opportunity. It would have been so easy to raise the threshold in line with the state pension, and keep them aligned. This simple mechanism would ensure that those with no other income pay no tax, and keep a little more money in the pockets of working people and others on very low incomes. Maybe next year? Jack Kenward South Molton, North Devon

Although abolishing the standing charge is something I agree with, presumably one of the groups that will benefit are second (and third) home owners. This includes approximately 177 MPs, Airbnb properties and holiday lets. John Victor Davies Hastings, East Sussex

I know that things are tight, but could the government not have funded a red box with “CR III” painted on it rather than the “ER II” sported by Mr Healey? Robert Bowden Bristol

  • budget
  • burnham
  • andy
  • rhetoric
  • tax
  • aditya
  • chakrabortty
  • martin

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Andy Burnham heads to Brussels as UK and EU close in on Brexit reset deal – live
politics

Andy Burnham heads to Brussels as UK and EU close in on Brexit reset deal – live

UK and EU have provisionally agreed to allow 100,000 EU citizens to come to the UK every year under a new mobility scheme. Senior correspondent France’s insistence that the UK could not have voting rights at any stage during the shaping of legislation on food standards and public health risks relating to food and agri products is a line in the sand for Andy Burnham.

Read →
From Germany, with love: a letter to the UK
politics

From Germany, with love: a letter to the UK

As Andy Burnham pushes to reopen Brexit, Berlin won’t say it, but the truth is, we just want you back Dear British friends, Germans are not the love-letter writing kind of people. Klaus Brinkbäumer, a former executive editor at Der Spiegel, is an author and podcast and TV host in Germany Continue reading...

Read →
Cap all political donations, not only those from overseas, Burnham told
politics

Cap all political donations, not only those from overseas, Burnham told

Experts say ‘insanely complex’ £100,000 limit proposed for overseas donors should be replaced by universal cap Andy Burnham is facing calls to commit to a cap on all political donations when the elections bill is in the House of Lords, instead of the “insanely complex” £100,000 limit on overseas donors. The Labour former home secretary David Blunkett is one of many peers to have tabled an amendment calling for an overall cap, proposing a £500,000 annual limit per donor, with his plan believed to have broad support.

Read →
Cross-border real-time VAT to generate at least GH¢2.5bn in first year, GRA projects
business

Cross-border real-time VAT to generate at least GH¢2.5bn in first year, GRA projects

The full implementation of the real-time Value Added Tax (VAT) system will begin in January next year, with the Ghana Revenue Authority (GRA) expecting to generate more than GH¢2.5 billion for the country in its first year. Speaking at the post-budget forum, Commissioner-General of the Ghana Revenue Authority, Anthony Sarpong, disclosed that the real-time VAT system on cross-border trade would help address revenue gaps in tax collection, with more than GH¢2.5 billion expected to be generated in the first year of implementation.

Read →
business

Businesses could face higher tax costs despite no new taxes in 2027 Budget – Deloitte warns

Deloitte Ghana has cautioned businesses that the absence of new taxes in the 2027 Budget Statement and Economic Policy does not mean tax costs will remain unchanged but could witness an increase in the effective tax cost due to a series of tax policy and administration reforms. Unveiling Deloitte’s highlights of the 2027 budget, Daniel Owusu, Country Managing Partner of Deloitte Ghana, reinforced the need for businesses to look beyond tax rates and assess the broader implications of the Budget’s tax reform agenda on operations, investments and compliance obligations.

Read →
Asian stocks headed for worst week since 2020 as Anthropic IPO fails to end AI rout – business live
business

Asian stocks headed for worst week since 2020 as Anthropic IPO fails to end AI rout – business live

The CSI 300 (-1.85%), Shanghai Composite (-2.10%), and Australia’s S&P/ASX 200 (-1.58%) are also posting notable declines. 7am GMT: ONS public finances, ONS retail sales 3pm GMT: University of Michigan’s consumer confidence report for November Today: UK-EU summit – Andy Burnham will meet António Costa, President of the European Council, and Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission, in Brussels on 20 November 2026 for the second UK-EU summit Continue reading...

Read →