entertainment

Alex Garland’s Elden Ring adaptation is on course to be Hollywood’s goriest ever fantasy movie

Alex Garland’s Elden Ring adaptation is on course to be Hollywood’s goriest ever fantasy movie

The Golden Compass diluted Philip Pullman’s theological bite, Warcraft thought that just explaining its world would make us care about it, and The Dark Tower compressed Stephen King’s sprawling mythology so ruthlessly that it scarcely left room for a story. Which brings us to the forthcoming Alex Garland adaptation of the hugely popular high fantasy video game, Elden Ring.

The expansive project has hype and money behind it – but how do you avoid it falling into the disappointment trap so many films end up stumbling into?

If the history of failed Hollywood fantasy projects over the past 20 years has taught us anything, it is that transporting audiences to another world is only half the battle: you also have to give them a reason to spend several hours there. The Golden Compass diluted Philip Pullman’s theological bite, Warcraft thought that just explaining its world would make us care about it, and The Dark Tower compressed Stephen King’s sprawling mythology so ruthlessly that it scarcely left room for a story. All these films at one point had fans of the original source material quivering with anticipation at the prospect of seeing their beloved worlds on the big screen; all ended up disappointing.

Which brings us to the forthcoming Alex Garland adaptation of the hugely popular high fantasy video game, Elden Ring. If there was ever a cinematic test of the phrase “too big to fail”, it is surely this. Elden Ring has sold more than 30m copies and is widely regarded as one of the greatest video games ever made. George RR Martin himself wrote the foundational mythology of warring demigods that underpins its gorgeous fantasy hellscape. And Garland as writer-director seems almost impossibly perfect: as the creative behind Dredd, Ex Machina and Annihilation, he has both the taste for beautiful nightmares and the geek credentials to deliver something extraordinary.

It appears the movie has already been shot and is in post-production, with a cast including Cailee Spaeny, Ben Whishaw, Nick Offerman, Sonoya Mizuno, Peter Serafinowicz and Jonathan Pryce. Amazon MGM has reportedly snapped up streaming rights across numerous international markets, while theatrical distribution rights are being touted at November’s American Film Market, where it will reportedly be the most expensive stand-alone project ever offered for sale. Deadline suggests the budget is close to $200m, which ought to pay for at least a couple of Elden Ring’s repulsive resident monstrosities’ more expensive mutations.

And that’s the thing about the game: it veers far closer to full-on horror than anything we’ve seen so far in mainstream Hollywood swords and sorcery. There are creatures with writhing worms for faces. There are enormous, bodiless hand spiders that scuttle about on eight or more fingers. There are mechanical iron maidens that hurtle towards you on wheels, swinging enormous blades, before their bellies spring open and a nest of snakes drags you into the machinery.

If the far more wholesome The Lord of the Rings was once considered unfilmable, what hope for a fantasy world where almost everyone is dead and the survivors are coping by eating their lovers’ corpses? Will there even be a hero in this thing for audiences to pin their hopes on?

In the game, you hack, slash and spellcast through a zillion dead things before taking on the various demigods in final boss battles, but that can’t and won’t be the extent of the film. Perhaps Garland will draw on the Martin-inspired backstory of how the Lands Between descended into death and destruction in the first place. Leaked images suggest a Leyndell (this world’s capital) populated by living people and hint at the execution of a hideous character known as the Dung Eater (a pre-game event), all of which suggests some sort of prequel might be in play.

It’s hard to see a happy ending here, but perhaps that’s the point. After all, Garland has a record of denying audiences conventional Hollywood-style reassurance. In Annihilation, he brought a married couple back together while leaving us wondering whether either remained human; in Ex Machina, he let the gorgeous AI escape and left her would-be rescuer locked up to die; in Civil War, he overthrew a tyrant but made the victory photograph look like evidence for a future war crimes tribunal. The uncertainty is whether he will get the same freedom with a film costing close to $200m. At the very least, prospective purchasers need to be aware that they are unlikely to be buying the 2026 equivalent of a return to the Shire. Unless, of course, they want a world where something has eaten the hobbits and is now wearing them.

  • fantasy
  • garland
  • elden
  • ring
  • alex
  • adaptation
  • hollywood
  • world

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Cop31 failed but in ‘the real world’ the transition away from fossil fuels is inevitable
science

Cop31 failed but in ‘the real world’ the transition away from fossil fuels is inevitable

The summit’s failure was due to a refusal to admit we cannot confront the climate crisis without shifting to renewables The failure of Cop31 will be measured not in inches of negotiating text, or bland promises made by ministers and officials, but in lives and livelihoods, in hopes dashed and hardship endured, community leaders from around the world have warned. “Cop31 failed because it refused to name the issue at the core of climate change: fossil fuels,” said Edson Krenak, an Indigenous leader from Brazil and member of the Cultural Survival network.

Read →
Cop31 climate talks set to end in deep division as key deal rejected
science

Cop31 climate talks set to end in deep division as key deal rejected

Two weeks of fierce negotiations all but collapse as some decisions pass, but main text objected to by EU, UK and some of developing world The EU, the UK and allies in the developing world rejected what they called an unacceptable deal on the future of the climate, which failed even to mention fossil fuels, in a dramatic finish to the Cop31 UN talks in Turkey. The proposed deal “failed to meet the moment”, said Ireland’s environment minister Darragh O’Brien, speaking for the EU.

Read →
‘Harsh to be under her thumb’: Pitchfork’s Ryan Schreiber on selling to Condé Nast and Anna Wintour
entertainment

‘Harsh to be under her thumb’: Pitchfork’s Ryan Schreiber on selling to Condé Nast and Anna Wintour

For the first time since leaving, he opens up about his new life as an out gay man and why he quit On the early November day that I met Pitchfork founder Ryan Schreiber in New York City, the website he created is all that anyone on my timeline can talk about, again. It’s an all-timer, up there with Phoebe Bridgers saying that she thinks about the site’s review of Jet’s second album (a video of a monkey pissing in its own mouth) once a day, and Halsey wishing that the Pitchfork office, which is on the site of the 9/11 attacks in New York, would “collapse already”.

Read →
A textural moment: why the fashion world is falling in love with opera coats
lifestyle

A textural moment: why the fashion world is falling in love with opera coats

From Jennifer Lawrence to Kate Moss, the fuzz-trimmed garments are proving popular with celebrities, while others are DIY-ing their way into the trend While puffer jackets have dominated winter wardrobes for years, this winter an alternative is emerging: the fuzz-trimmed opera coat. Originally worn over formal evening gowns, new interpretations come in floor-grazing and cropped styles and are being worn with everything from minidresses to jeans.

Read →