Firmus talks down 'modest' data centre in bid to avoid major project status
Firmus wants one of its proposed Tasmanian data centres assessed through normal planning processes, saying it has only "modest" economic benefits despite earlier saying its plans for the state could add $46 billion to the local economy.
Firmus Technologies says one of its AI data centres should not be assessed as a major project.
The company argues that unlike other major projects, the data centre has only "modest" economic benefits and about 20 ongoing jobs.
The State Planning Office is assessing the major project proposal made by the Latrobe Council.
Firmus Technologies is fighting a local council push for one of its proposed AI data centres to be declared a major project.
Latrobe Council in Tasmania's north-west has sought to defer a decision on Firmus's proposed 52-megawatt Wesley Vale AI data centre to the state government.
It has said the council's 1993 planning scheme is dated and councillors would not be able to consider all the relevant issues, such as energy, water and environmental impacts of a large AI data centre.
A letter from Firmus's lawyers to Planning Minister Kerry Vincent, which is assessing the request for a major project declaration, has now been made public.
"We respectfully ask that the Wesley Vale Computing Infrastructure not be declared a major project," the letter reads.
It states that the project would have only "modest" economic benefits and ongoing job opportunities.
Although the Wesley Vale Computing Infrastructure is expected to generate some economic activity, these benefits are relatively modest and largely confined to employment opportunities, with approximately 70 jobs anticipated during the construction phase and around 20 permanent full-time positions once operational.
Beyond these direct employment outcomes, the Wesley Vale Computing Infrastructure is not expected to materially alter the economic structure of the region, establish a significant new industry cluster, or drive broader regional economic transformation.
The submission states the development cost of its facility would be $31.25 million and it would support about 20 ongoing jobs.
It compared this to major projects such as Chambroad's Kangaroo Bay Hotel proposal near Hobart, which it said would support 443 ongoing jobs and generate $42.7 million in additional annual visitor expenditure.
"The economic benefits of the Wesley Vale Computing Infrastructure are considerably more limited in scale and are largely confined to construction activity and a relatively modest number of ongoing jobs," the letter reads.
The process of declaring and assessing a major project in Tasmania can take years, while the council approval process is usually much quicker.
Last week, at a Tasmanian parliamentary inquiry into AI data centres, Firmus co-CEO Tim Rosenfield was asked about the benefits to Tasmania of its three projects in the state.
"This is a large-scale investment we're making," he told the inquiry.
"We have actually, at the request of the government some months ago, commissioned a third-party study which is close to being finalised.
"It puts total state gross product contributions of up to $46 billion to the Tasmanian state economy through 2035.
"We're operating these supercomputers, and that requires skills, it requires on-site presence, it requires learning pathways.
"The preliminary modelled outcome shows about 8,900 ongoing FTEs [full-time equivalent jobs] through 2035 created."
Firmus is building an AI data centre in the Launceston suburb of St Leonards and has approval for another at Long Reach in northern Tasmania.
In addition to saying the economic impact of the project would not be "significant" to the region, the letter from Firmus's lawyers also said the impact on the area's environment and social fabric would be limited.
It also said the project would not deliver advanced regional development objectives or significant public infrastructure to the region.
The letter said the proposal was not complex from a planning perspective, and suitable to be considered by the council under the planning scheme.
"It does not involve the jurisdictional, regulatory, or statutory complexities typically associated with projects assessed under the major projects framework, such as cross-municipal development, multiple approval pathways, or the need for planning scheme amendments," the letter reads.
Firmus's lawyers also expressed "concern" with Latrobe Council's decision to ask for the development to be considered a major project, pointing out the development application had been submitted to council back in late May.
"Since that time, council has accepted the application, reviewed the supporting technical reports, requested further information, considered amended documentation, and progressed the application to public exhibition," the submission states.
"Our client is deeply disappointed that, after the application has advanced through these stages of assessment, council has now taken the position that the Wesley Vale Computing Infrastructure should instead be referred for consideration under the Major Projects framework.
"Had council genuinely considered that the Wesley Vale Computing Infrastructure should be assessed under the major projects framework, it would be reasonable to expect that this issue would have been identified and raised at an earlier stage of the assessment process."
- firmus
- centre
- datum
- bid
- project
- status
- planning
- process



