Why dismiss ‘reel-makers’ when police rely on reels: women media professionals ask in Supreme Court

Network of Women in Media, India says journalists’ entitlement to undertake lawful newsgathering from public places cannot be made contingent upon State accreditation; Article 19(1)(a) is not confined to material which the police chooses to recognise as ‘news’, it says
Journalists with the independent online news platform, are taken away following their detention during a Cockroach Janta Party protest demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. File.
Network of Women in Media, India, a women journalists’ group, responded to the Delhi Police in the Supreme Court on Saturday (November 21, 2026) that the freedom to gather and report news is not dependent upon State accreditation, formal employment with a recognised media organisation, or possession of an employer-issued identity card.
The police had distinguished between accredited reporters from established media houses and reel-makers, saying the latter was not in the same league as journalists.
The women journalists’ group, which is a petitioner challenging the en masse removal and detentions, particularly of reporters covering the October protests demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, questioned the condescension for ‘reels’ when the short video format was widely used not only by major newsrooms but also the Delhi Police, All India Radio and the Press Information Bureau to disseminate information.
While the police criticise ‘reel-makers’, it has no compunction about turning to Instagram reels to allege misconduct by persons present at the protest sites, the women media professionals pointed out.
NWMI said Central government data for 2024-25 showed a total advertisement expenditure of ₹525.9 crore across print and audio-visual media, of which ₹406.12 crore, or 77.2%, was for audio-visual advertisements. State governments, including Uttar Pradesh, Haryana and Karnataka, have themselves adopted digital-media advertisement policies or guidelines.
“Independent journalists, freelancers and journalists working through digital platforms form an established and legitimate part of the contemporary press, and their entitlement to undertake lawful newsgathering from public places cannot be made contingent upon State accreditation,” NWMI, represented by advocate Aarthi Rajan, countered the Delhi Police in a rejoinder filed in the apex court.
The Delhi Police, in its latest affidavit on November 16, said reel-makers cannot be considered as working journalists. It maintained the protection afforded by the Supreme Court’s orders to not hinder journalists at work in anti-CEC protests did not trickle down to “reel-makers, social media influencers or unruly elements” who break the law, and any individual with a camera and mic cannot be termed a journalist. The police had complained that YouTube content creators swarmed the protest so much that security personnel had difficulty distinguishing between journalists and reel-makers in the melee.
The NWMI said the record has to be set straight. For one, accreditation was no concession or grant of a favour by the State to journalists. It was merely an acknowledgment on the part of the State of a right and professional reality that already existed independently of the accreditation regime.
Hence, the State cannot use the excuse of absenceor “supposed inadequacy” of professional credentials as an explanation for police interference against journalists engaged in reporting.
“An accreditation framework designed to facilitate specified access or privileges cannot be converted into a police licensing regime for journalism, much less into a threshold condition for the exercise of press freedom and lawful newsgathering from public places,” women media professionals submitted.
The NWMI said the police’s use of the label ‘reel-makers’ seemed to be a retrospective justification for the obstruction and detention of journalists.
If the police could not distinguish between reel-makers and journalists, there was no identifiable criterion by which officers could have isolated a separate category of so-called ‘reel-makers’. Conversely, if officers were capable of making that distinction, removing journalists who visibly displayed press credentials was deliberate rather than a case of mistaken identity, NWMI argued.
“The relevant question is what the person was doing — recording police action at a public protest for publication is newsgathering and dissemination, irrespective of the duration, format or platform employed. Article 19(1)(a) protects the freedom of speech and expression of every citizen and is not confined to material which the police chooses to recognise as ‘news’,” the rejoinder said.
Obstruction, forcible removal, assault or sexual harassment directed at journalists strike simultaneously at their personal liberty and bodily integrity, their freedom to practise their vocation, and the freedom of the press to gather and communicate information.
To a submission by the Delhi Police that there was no statutory mandate that only women police personnel could handle women protestors as part of crowd-control measures, the NWMI contended that dragging, lifting, carrying and confinement in a police vehicle or transportation, in substance, amounted to arrest. The police cannot avoid safeguards provided for women by calling the act ‘crowd control’ or ‘removal’.
“Crowd-control is not a zone in which a woman’s dignity and bodily integrity stand reduced,” women media professionals said.
- police
- reel
- supreme
- court
- women
- media
- maker
- woman





