politics

Intervention not jail: youth crime plea ahead of Victorian election

Intervention not jail: youth crime plea ahead of Victorian election

Youth advocates are calling for a greater focus on early intervention for juvenile offenders, arguing that current hardline approaches are costly and ineffective.

Youth advocates are calling for a focus on early intervention for juvenile offenders, arguing hardline approaches are costly and ineffective.

Both major parties are pledging tough responses to youth crime, with the Liberals promising boot camps for some juveniles and Labor pledging mandatory rehabilitation detention for low- and mid-level offenders.

Detaining a youth in Victoria costs more than $2.6 million per detainee a year.

After migrating from New Zealand with her family as a child, Falé changed schools constantly.

"It was difficult making friends if I was always moving, so at year 8, I just stopped getting comfortable," she said.

Grieving and caring for six siblings while her mother went back to NZ to care for her own parents, Falé left her studies and began working to pay the bills.

She says "a mix of grief, anger and stress" eventually led to violence.

"It was a one-time altercation," she said, adding that — in retrospect — "there were better ways of handling the situation".

Juveniles account for 11.6 per cent of the state's total alleged offending.

Recently released Crime Statistics Agency data for the year to June 2026 showed alleged youth offender incidents dropped 8.1 per cent compared with the previous year.

However, a series of high-profile violent crimes by young people in recent years has kept the issue in the spotlight, fuelling election promises of tighter bail and tougher sentences.

Labor has a new "tough love" policy of mandatory youth rehabilitation detention with low- and mid-level offenders to be held in a "secure residential youth justice facility" for up to 12 months.

The Liberals have pledged to send some juveniles to "boot camp" in regional Victoria.

Labor, the Coalition and One Nation also support "adult time for violent crime", with juveniles given the same sentences as adults for serious crimes such as home invasion, carjacking, burglary and armed robbery.

The Greens strongly oppose these policies and both major parties have pledged some support for community-based intervention programs.

But Victorian youth service providers say there is too much focus on incarceration.

Blake Edwards is the CEO of the Youth Junction Inc, a youth services provider in Sunshine in Melbourne's western suburbs.

Mr Edwards said there needed to be "high levels of consequences" for violent crime, but argued there should be equal amounts of funding for early intervention.

"The support services are stretched [and] underfunded, and that's a real concern," Mr Edwards said.

Jamie Crosby from the Centre for Excellence in Child and Family Welfare, a peak body, said increasing the number of child offenders sent to detention was not only costly but did not work.

"It's really about intervening at the first sign of trouble," Mr Crosby said.

"How do we divert them away from escalating the type of offending behaviour which is putting communities on edge?"

Mr Crosbie said detention might keep the community safe while the offender is in custody, but the problems often escalate when they get out.

"When they reintegrate into the community … there's a much higher likelihood that the very type of behaviour that's causing people to be concerned is perpetuated."

Victoria is one of the highest spending jurisdictions in the country when it comes to juvenile detention.

The latest Productivity Commission Report on Government Services found that detaining a single youth in Victoria costs $7,304 a day, or more than $2.6 million per detainee per year.

That is more than twice the national average of $3,600 per youth prisoner a day.

Mr Edwards said intervention was cheaper, more effective and had better outcomes for offenders and victims.

"It costs $11 per person per day (for community-based programs) and the outcomes that we're seeing are quality," he said.

Since 2016, the Victorian government has allocated about $40 million to organisations that provide mentoring and case-management services to at-risk young people under its Youth Crime Prevention Program (YCPP).

But a recent report from the Victorian Auditor-General's Office found no evidence the YCPP led to a reduction in offending.

The report said numbers for most organisations were too small to draw strong conclusions from, and record-keeping was poor, which raised the risk of "performance and accountability gaps".

However, it said results from a number of organisations, including Youth Junction, were "encouraging".

Mr Edwards argued that re-offending should not be the only way of measuring success.

"Offending behaviour is a really important part, but we also need to look at the level of risk that a young person presents with," he said.

"Have they re-engaged with education and employment? Have they reconnected with their family and their communities? Have they disengaged from harmful peers?

"If we're seeing positive changes in those spaces, then what will eventually happen is offending behaviour will reduce.

One Nation also wants to lower the age of criminal responsibility from 12 to 10, arguing that a child "knows the difference between right and wrong".

But Mr Edwards said children were not physiologically capable of making complex decisions.

"A young person's brain is under rapid development and the area of responsibility for complex thought is diverted to the area that's responsible for how you feel," he said.

Now 24, Falé said coming to Youth Junction stopped her life spiralling further.

"It was a big difference because, coming here, I was focusing on myself and I didn't have to worry about my siblings," she said.

"This is probably the first place that made me think about what I really wanted to do for my future."

The auditor-general's report also singled out the programs at Banksia Gardens Community Services in Broadmeadows as showing promise.

Banksia Gardens youth program manager Paul Atkinson told the ABC there was no evidence that harsher punishments reduced crime.

"But if we concentrate all of our efforts at the end point after a serious crime has been done, we're not actually addressing the issue of crime, we're just making ourselves feel better."

Mr Atkinson said spending time in custody often led to further offending.

"They become associated with other people who are also offending. They're developing a self-identity as an offender," he said.

Maw is a 25-year-old father of two with a passion for music and his Christian faith.

But as a 14-year-old with time on his hands, he drifted into drugs and crime.

"I was disengaged from school," Maw said.

"My mum was working, so often I was left at home by myself, and one day I just came across the wrong crowd."

He soon began coming into contact with police, but it had little impact on his behaviour.

Eventually Maw found his way to a church youth justice program.

He is now a youth leader, along with 24-year-old Nachida, who also got into serious trouble as a teen.

"I started to get myself involved in the wrong crowd — smoking, drinking, partying," Nachida explained.

"Starts off small, but one thing leads to another and things got worse along the line."

Nachida and Maw both believed early intervention and support could have helped them, and others, avoid a lot of grief.

"It does take time," Nachida said. "But I knew that I wanted to change."

  • intervention
  • youth
  • jail
  • crime
  • plea
  • election
  • advocate
  • focus

Summaries and tags are generated automatically. Stay informed with VidiaNews.

Related news

Kindiki Warns Politicians Against Divisive Rhetoric Ahead of 2027 General Election
politics

Kindiki Warns Politicians Against Divisive Rhetoric Ahead of 2027 General Election

NAIROBI, Kenya Nov 21 – Deputy President Kithure Kindiki has urged politicians to avoid divisive rhetoric and incitement to violence ahead of the 2027 General Election, warning that ethnic mobilisation could undermine national unity and trigger conflict. Accompanied by Nakuru Governor Susan Kihika, Nakuru Town East MP David Gikaria and Nakuru Woman Representative Lisa Chelule, Kindiki said political competition should not translate into enmity, adding that the best candidates should win through a democratic process.

Read →
LP condemns rising political violence ahead of 2027 polls
politics

LP condemns rising political violence ahead of 2027 polls

By John Alechenu, Abuja The Labour Party (LP) has condemned the rising cases of politically motivated violence across the country ahead of the 2027 general elections, warning that the trend poses a threat to democracy and national stability. The National Publicity Secretary of the party, Ken Asogwa, stated this in an interview with Vanguard in Abuja, where he appealed to political parties and their supporters to exercise restraint in their conduct and utterances.

Read →