Remembering Australia's worst naval disaster 'limited' due to council woes
On the 85th anniversary of the sinking of HMAS Sydney, the Naval Association of Australia says it had to scale down proposed commemorative events because of a lack of cooperation from a local government.
Events have been held to commemorate the 85th anniversary of the sinking of HMAS Sydney off WA's north-west coast.
The Naval Association of Australia says plans for larger events for this year's anniversary could not happen because the Shire of Carnarvon was not properly functioning.
Carnarvon shire commissioner Martin Aldridge says the shire welcomes further discussions on a military tourism trail.
The Naval Association of Australia says efforts to hold events for the 85th anniversary of Australia's worst naval disaster were limited because one shire council was dissolved.
The HMAS Sydney II was a light cruiser caught in conflict with the German raider HSK Kormoran off the coast of Carnarvon, almost 900 kilometres north of Perth.
All 645 of its crew were lost, 317 of the Kormoran's crew survived, and 103 of them made it to shore, near a farming station, about 100km north of Carnarvon.
Carnarvon is not the only place that commemorates the disaster, with the Mid West city of Geraldton being the last port the HMAS Sydney docked at before it sank.
The wreckage was not found until 2008 off Shark Bay's coast, between Geraldton and Carnarvon.
Naval Association of Australia state president Ian Holthouse wanted a military tourism trail that collaborated with local businesses from Quobba Station in the north to Geraldton in the south for the 85th anniversary.
"If we tie up Geraldton and Carnarvon and have a HMAS Sydney week, if the local governments can work together," he said.
Mr Holthouse initially contacted the Shire of Carnarvon president earlier in the year.
However, it was not long after that contact that the Carnarvon council was dissolved.
"Unfortunately, with Carnarvon not having a council, there was no-one there to authorise and put it together," Mr Holthouse said.
Mr Holthouse said the City of Greater Geraldton was already on board and he hoped Carnarvon would be ready by next year or they would miss out on benefiting from their own history.
"I know the new council will have a lot more priorities than this, but I would like to see them take it on seriously because they have a chance to make this a tourist experience coming off Geraldton."
A small service was held in Carnarvon the week prior to mark the momentous occasion with refurbished plaques being unveiled, but Geraldton hosted its own service for the 85th anniversary of the sinking, November 19.
Carnarvon shire commissioner Martin Aldridge said the council was pleased to practically support the service this year through event set-up and the installation of new plaques on the memorial.
"The proposed military tourism trail presents an opportunity to further highlight our region's historical significance and strengthen connections between important heritage locations," he said.
"While the shire has not yet had the opportunity to formally consider the proposal, we welcome further discussions with the Naval Association to better understand its vision and explore opportunities for future collaboration."
Carnarvon Heritage Group president Dudley Maslen said stories about what happened 85 years ago continued to be told.
"My mother was here at the time. Everyone was in disbelief that the Sydney had gone, and they believed the survivors that had been spotted and picked up off the coast were from the Sydney sank," he said.
"Everyone went around the neighbouring stations and got mattresses and that from the shearing sheds from around the place to make sure the people had something to sleep on."
The Sydney and Kormoran had a lasting effect on the community. Mr Maslen said he remembered a local named Tommy Bird who wore a German sailor's hat for the rest of his life, after the disaster.
"The story was he was standing there as a 10 or 12-year-old watching these prisoners come in from Quobba on a truck, and one of the German sailors threw his cap," he said.
"And I must say, I never saw Tommy without that cap."
Mr Maslen said it would be a shame if all the commemoration was done in Geraldton, and Carnarvon missed out.
"I think there should be a memorial in just about every town in Australia to these people," he said.
- remembering
- australia
- disaster
- council
- naval
- woe
- anniversary
- sinking


